if you want a winger to beat a LB all day, AV the man but if you want a winger to beat the whole left field, Nani is the one

In the past two performances, Nani has done little wrong and shown more development in his play and decision-making. It's great to see him show more maturity in his play. I hope he gets a start in the next match against Everton. They are tight at the back and pretty solid, so Nani will be key here.

Jesus christ... the compairing wont take an end.... can't believe how ignorant some of the posts in the thread are... Why do so many of you feel the need to blast one of our players because you like another? Again theese two players bring completely different elements to our game, which is a giant bonus.

Zishan:

Simon H:

nemanja fikri:

For me after yesterday performance, he give us extra energy to our attacking.....young is great player.....but if nani get his form, he is even better than valencia....

"If" being the operative word. Nani is inconsistent, either brilliant or poor. At least with Valencia you know what you are getting 99 times out of 100.

I rate Valencia > Nani >Young . Valencia Consistent, Efficient and he take on his man. Nani More talented but not inconsistent Young just had 5 good matches does not know how to use his speed. ALWAYS TURN TO HIS RIGHT FOOT FOR CROSSING. TOO predictable and born with two right foot. Id take Lennon in his place anytime.

Would lennon have powered taht shot past robinson against blackburn? I dont think so. Shut your pie hole

xavier_sotomayor:

Nani is the best winger in the whole PL. I rate him better than Valencia. Nani has more to offer as far as attacking, shooting scoring... and can use both of his feet. We all know Valencia can't use his left foot to save his life!

totally agree mate..

I've always preferred Nani to Valencia, just for the simple fact that every time i see Valencia play I am like... urrggghhh.... practice your LEFT in training. Nani has great talent but his block is psychological. He either gets very arrogant or very low in morale. If he could straighten that out he'd be the best. I think both Nani and Valencia bring more to the team than Young, even though he is capable of some amazing stuff.

i think that nani shud start playing we can put ashley young just behind wayne rooney

Simon H:

nemanja fikri:

For me after yesterday performance, he give us extra energy to our attacking.....young is great player.....but if nani get his form, he is even better than valencia....

"If" being the operative word. Nani is inconsistent, either brilliant or poor. At least with Valencia you know what you are getting 99 times out of 100.

I rate Valencia > Nani >Young . Valencia Consistent, Efficient and he take on his man. Nani More talented but not inconsistent Young just had 5 good matches does not know how to use his speed. ALWAYS TURN TO HIS RIGHT FOOT FOR CROSSING. TOO predictable and born with two right foot. Id take Lennon in his place anytime.

nemanja fikri:

Simon H:

nemanja fikri:

For me after yesterday performance, he give us extra energy to our attacking.....young is great player.....but if nani get his form, he is even better than valencia....

"If" being the operative word. Nani is inconsistent, either brilliant or poor. At least with Valencia you know what you are getting 99 times out of 100.

There are no word "confirm" about people performance....they are human not robot....and for valencia case im not sure whether he is human or robot....LOL

Even Valencia he is sometimes ineffective. I remember against Blackburn, most of his crosses were not dangerous until he tried that shot, but you could see when Giggs came in the crosses became threatening. Against Barca Valencia didn't do much so don't talk like Nani is the only one with the problem.

Simon H:

"If" being the operative word. Nani is inconsistent, either brilliant or poor. At least with Valencia you know what you are getting 99 times out of 100.

The amusing thing is even being supposedly inconsistent, Nani's stats put him up there in the top 3 wingers in the world (One being Ronaldo and then Nani and Mata battling for the 2nd and 3rd spot).

xavier_sotomayor:

Unitedadmirer:

xavier_sotomayor:

Nani is the best winger in the whole PL. I rate him better than Valencia. Nani has more to offer as far as attacking, shooting scoring... and can use both of his feet. We all know Valencia can't use his left foot to save his life!

After reading: Re: Valencia >> Ronaldo Maybe in another lifetime... I don't think Valencia will be better than Ronaldo ever. There is no way he has pace like Ronaldo does, and he can't shoot with his left foot if his life depended on it. On the other hand I think Obertain has more talent to become close to Ronaldo. It just depends if he is hard worker like Ronaldo ... Posted to General United Discussion (Forum) by xavier_sotomayor on 17 Dec 2009, time proved that Valencia is better than Overtan and that he is not less than Nani. AV25 does not need his left foot to save his life, his right foot is enough.

Well I'm human after all.. But I still think Nani is better than Valencia who's only "skill" is speed. That's why whenever we play in Europe other teams don't have problems marking him.. because everybody knows he is going to the right.. can't cut inside.. even if he does he passes the ball back. Agree to disagree ;)

I still belive that Valencia in not less than Nani, considering also the defense attitude. Sir Ferguson has the last word.

On form, I feel Nani is our best winger. If he is able to find a bit of form between now and the end of the season, he will play a massive part in us winning the league.

Unitedadmirer:

xavier_sotomayor:

Nani is the best winger in the whole PL. I rate him better than Valencia. Nani has more to offer as far as attacking, shooting scoring... and can use both of his feet. We all know Valencia can't use his left foot to save his life!

After reading: Re: Valencia >> Ronaldo Maybe in another lifetime... I don't think Valencia will be better than Ronaldo ever. There is no way he has pace like Ronaldo does, and he can't shoot with his left foot if his life depended on it. On the other hand I think Obertain has more talent to become close to Ronaldo. It just depends if he is hard worker like Ronaldo ... Posted to General United Discussion (Forum) by xavier_sotomayor on 17 Dec 2009, time proved that Valencia is better than Overtan and that he is not less than Nani. AV25 does not need his left foot to save his life, his right foot is enough.

Well I'm human after all.. But I still think Nani is better than Valencia who's only "skill" is speed. That's why whenever we play in Europe other teams don't have problems marking him.. because everybody knows he is going to the right.. can't cut inside.. even if he does he passes the ball back. Agree to disagree ;)

xavier_sotomayor:

Nani is the best winger in the whole PL. I rate him better than Valencia. Nani has more to offer as far as attacking, shooting scoring... and can use both of his feet. We all know Valencia can't use his left foot to save his life!

After reading: Re: Valencia >> Ronaldo Maybe in another lifetime... I don't think Valencia will be better than Ronaldo ever. There is no way he has pace like Ronaldo does, and he can't shoot with his left foot if his life depended on it. On the other hand I think Obertain has more talent to become close to Ronaldo. It just depends if he is hard worker like Ronaldo ... Posted to General United Discussion (Forum) by xavier_sotomayor on 17 Dec 2009, time proved that Valencia is better than Overtan and that he is not less than Nani. AV25 does not need his left foot to save his life, his right foot is enough.

Pretty decent performance. Even got a goal from himself, with left foot, Mr Valencia. Good finish, hard, low and near post. If the ball was a bit higher, Given would have saved easily. Great finish.