imo the best reserve players this season go in this order...

1. Davide Petrucci (not sure how he didn't get nominated he's been awesome), 2. Paul Pogba (his quality shows in every game), 3. Jesse Lingard (I think he's been great this season), 4. Will Keane, 5. Michael Keane

These 5 imo have all been terrific this season.

Jesse Lingard is my pick. He reminds me of a young Paul Scholes.

Saying that, I can't understand how Paul Pogba, Davide Petrucci and Will Keane particularly haven't been included in the list. They're three exceptional young talents.

Their is an exceptional amount of talent in our Academy/Reserve teams at the moment and I don't expect them all to make the first team but if 4-5 manage to carve out careers for themselves at the club, I think it would be a fantastic outcome for our youth system.

If they stay, I can see Zeki Fryers and Paul Pogba becoming established first team players in a couple of years and in my opinion Ryan Tunnicliffe, Jesse Lingard, Luke McCullough (Academy Captain), Joe Rothwell, Jack Rudge, Mats Daehli, Adnan Januzaj, Davide Petrucci, Will Keane and Jack Barmby all have an excellent chance of playing for the first team someday and at the very least performing regularly for a decent Premiership club.

It really is an exciting time at the moment.

garp01us:

Carlsberg King:

Should be WIll Keane or Petrucci in my eyes

agreed, I believe it is between these 2.

it should be one of these 2 but unfortunately Warren Joyce has not nominated them so its Michael Keane for me - M.U.F.C. O.K.

Will Keane....next aeason Berba/Owen and Macheda will be off and Keane will be ready to stake a claim...brilliant prospect.

Carlsberg King:

Should be WIll Keane or Petrucci in my eyes

agreed, I believe it is between these 2.

Lingaard or Michael Keane for Me.....

Moyesy:

mancrh:

Hahaha Lindegaard is a 27 year old back up goalie, Lingard is a 19 year old winger and Lindagaard doesn't exist. I'll vote for Lingard I think, though Michael is a close second for me. I'm surprised Cole is there ahead of Will Keane though.

Do you think its possible that Cole and maybe even M. Keane were put forward for the award as an ego boost. As a message to them that they are very good players in their own right dispite not being one of the players that are getting hyped up?

To be fair, Lingard ian't hyped at all. If anything, Cole was always seen as one of our best prospects, while before last season, Lingard and Michael were between the least favourite to make it (especially Lingard).

mancrh:

Hahaha Lindegaard is a 27 year old back up goalie, Lingard is a 19 year old winger and Lindagaard doesn't exist. I'll vote for Lingard I think, though Michael is a close second for me. I'm surprised Cole is there ahead of Will Keane though.

Do you think its possible that Cole and maybe even M. Keane were put forward for the award as an ego boost. As a message to them that they are very good players in their own right dispite not being one of the players that are getting hyped up?

I'll vote for Lingard , he was great this season. Some of his goals were absolute peaches too , very promising little player. Michael Keane has to be a close second though. Not only is he very reliable defensively , he's also good for scoring the odd goal too.

Should be WIll Keane or Petrucci in my eyes

lingard for me.

I'm surprised Pogba and Petrucci aren't in the list. I would vote for Lingard

i'm surprised Will Keane isn't there too.
i think i'll vote for Micheal Keane. but Lingard has been excellent.

mancrh:

Hahaha Lindegaard is a 27 year old back up goalie, Lingard is a 19 year old winger and Lindagaard doesn't exist. I'll vote for Lingard I think, though Michael is a close second for me. I'm surprised Cole is there ahead of Will Keane though.

my bad lol *jesse lingard

Hahaha Lindegaard is a 27 year old back up goalie, Lingard is a 19 year old winger and Lindagaard doesn't exist. I'll vote for Lingard I think, though Michael is a close second for me. I'm surprised Cole is there ahead of Will Keane though.