Gregory--roy:

I just wanted to know which players made ​​a good impression and who disappoint us this crazy season....Thoughts??? For me: 5 who SHINED-->Rooney,A.Valencia,Carrick,Evans,Young 5 who LET US DOWN-->Evra,Nani,Chicharito,Giggs,FERGIE

Surely this is a wind up?

Gregory--roy:

I just wanted to know which players made ​​a good impression and who disappoint us this crazy season....Thoughts??? For me: 5 who SHINED-->Rooney,A.Valencia,Carrick,Evans,Young 5 who LET US DOWN-->Evra,Nani,Chicharito,Giggs,FERGIE

5 players who shined : Rooney , Welbeck , Evans , Valencia & Carrick

5 players who let us down : Evra , Rafael , Nani . I dont remember anymore.

I'm trying not to be too negative at the moment so the 5 who shined were Rooney, Carrick, Evans, Valencia and Scholesy. However Evra needs to be told he's a left back not a left winger, ive been proper disappointed in him this season but I still believe he's one of the best full backs in the world at his best.

I'm only disappointed with the likes of Berbatov, Owen and Anderson who have a spot in the squad for no good reason.

Well, I'm disappointed with injuries too, but that's not any players fault.

5 who let us down: 1; RIO 2;EVRA; 3;HERNANDEZ 4; PARK 5;GIGGS 5 who shined: 1; EVANS 2;CARRICK 3;SCHOLES 4;VALENCIA(IN PARTS) 5;DE GEA(APART FROM FIRST 10 GAMES)

The 5 that shined: For sure Rooney, Valencia, Paul Scholes, Evans and sometimes Young The 5 that dissapointed: Rafael, Giggs. Evra, Berbatov, and Hernandez- where was he? And where was the chemistry between Rooney and him? If Berbatov and Park are done....STOP miliking it and send them on their way. Collect the money and buy someone else. Also Park was no where to be found this season!

Fergie let us down with his favouritism and poor selections..... I thot the defenders did ok given the absence of Vidic, our attack was poor but not shambolic, however the midfield is DIABOLICAL ... What exactly is the purpose of Carrick, he can tackle, he can't make a for ward pass, he can't content an aerial ball.... Boy, i missed Fletcher and Ando I hope for a better next year. Please buy us a defensive and a creative midfield ...and bring back Quieroz as chief coach, he is out of work anyway

Only 4 players who let us down Rafael, Evans, Evra, Ferdinand, Our defense lack of concentration is the key to our loss this season.

5 who shined: Rooney, Carrick, Evans, Welbeck, Valencia

5 who did not shine: Nani, Rafael, Evra... thats it

But FERGIE BUILDS UNITED

how has hernandez no they havent daft statment

I just wanted to know which players made ​​a good impression and who disappoint us this crazy season....Thoughts??? For me: 5 who SHINED-->Rooney,A.Valencia,Carrick,Evans,Young 5 who LET US DOWN-->Evra,Nani,Chicharito,Giggs,FERGIE