The views expressed on this noticeboard are expressed by the fans themselves and do not necessarily reflect the views of Manchester United or any of its representatives. The viewing and posting of messages on this noticeboard is subject to the Forum Terms, which can be viewed here.
Faq
Contact Us
Sort Posts:
Previous Next
  • 14 May 2012 5:34 PM

    Re: Season Overview: 5 players who shined and 5 who let us down

    Teddychizi:
    akulaII:
    Fergie let us down with his favouritism and poor selections..... I thot the defenders did ok given the absence of Vidic, our attack was poor but not shambolic, however the midfield is DIABOLICAL ... What exactly is the purpose of Carrick, he can tackle, he can't make a for ward pass, he can't content an aerial ball.... Boy, i missed Fletcher and Ando I hope for a better next year. Please buy us a defensive and a creative midfield ...and bring back Quieroz as chief coach, he is out of work anyway

    Are you actually saying you didn't see the purpose of Carrick, our best midfilelder this season?

    SCHOLES WAS BY FAR OUR best midfielder this season
    KagawaRVPRooneyValenciaCleverly
    Reply
  • 14 May 2012 5:28 PM

    Re: Season Overview: 5 players who shined and 5 who let us down

    kanea:
    Only 4 players who let us down Rafael, Evans, Evra, Ferdinand, Our defense lack of concentration is the key to our loss this season.
    Oh come off it, Evans and Ferdinand were key to us even being close... the Everton game aside. Sure we missed Vidic like hell but Evans should be commended not ridiculed. and Rafael hardly played this year and came in and had a couple of off games at a very key time in the season... costly errors yes but he can hardly be blamed he hardly played all season due to injury. I think the key to our loss this year is Injury and loss of concentration.

    But if theres anything positive to come out of this is they will be extremely hungry next year and if we can find a couple of key signings and have Chicharito hit his top form again then anything's possible! We should all just be positive now and move on!

    Sir Alex the Conqueror
    Reply
  • 14 May 2012 4:58 PM

    Re: Season Overview: 5 players who shined and 5 who let us down

    Shine: Rooney, Valencia, Carrick, Evans, Scholes Let us down: Rafael, Giggs, Park, Berbatov, Hernandez
    Reply
  • 14 May 2012 4:37 PM

    Re: Season Overview: 5 players who shined and 5 who let us down

    Gregory--roy:
    I just wanted to know which players made ​​a good impression and who disappoint us this crazy season....Thoughts??? For me: 5 who SHINED-->Rooney,A.Valencia,Carrick,Evans,Young 5 who LET US DOWN-->Evra,Nani,Chicharito,Giggs,FERGIE
    Very not funny. And terrible timing, sorry.
    Hindsight is 20 20
    Reply
  • 14 May 2012 4:36 PM

    Re: Season Overview: 5 players who shined and 5 who let us down

    Welbeck, Rooney, Valencia, Jonny, Carrick, shone.

    Reply
  • 14 May 2012 4:25 PM

    Re: Season Overview: 5 players who shined and 5 who let us down

    lord charles:
    Hernandez- where was he?
    yes, you know, the tiny 14 on front? who with much less minutes scores more goals than other teammate? I not trying to put down anyone on the team, but some of youse are very unfair with the boy, ah well, I sound like berba's brigade last season... be happy.
    Reply
  • 14 May 2012 4:23 PM

    Re: Season Overview: 5 players who shined and 5 who let us down

    5 who shined: Wayne Rooney, Ashley Young, Rio Ferdinand, David de Gea, Antonio Valencia. 5 who let us down: Ji-Sung Park, Rafael, Javier Hernandez, Ryan Giggs, Anderson. Extremely harsh putting Sir Alex in there.
    #thankyousiralex
    Reply
  • 14 May 2012 4:20 PM

    Re: Season Overview: 5 players who shined and 5 who let us down

    lord charles:
    5 that shined: with out a doubt Rooney, Paul Scholes, Evans, Valencia and Young. 5 that let us down: Berbatov, Owens, Rio, Rafael and Hernandes Where was the chemistry and creativity between Rooney and Hernandes when they played. Welbeck has better pace and is more physical than Hernandes and and Owen combined!
    and has the same goals that hernandez and owen in respective minutes of play, aye pal? oh wait...
    Reply
  • 14 May 2012 4:03 PM

    Re: Season Overview: 5 players who shined and 5 who let us down

    akulaII:
    Fergie let us down with his favouritism and poor selections..... I thot the defenders did ok given the absence of Vidic, our attack was poor but not shambolic, however the midfield is DIABOLICAL ... What exactly is the purpose of Carrick, he can tackle, he can't make a for ward pass, he can't content an aerial ball.... Boy, i missed Fletcher and Ando I hope for a better next year. Please buy us a defensive and a creative midfield ...and bring back Quieroz as chief coach, he is out of work anyway
    You do realise that many others have included Carrick as one of those who shined? If Carrick's critics here can say hes had a good season, its rather unfortunate that you have revealed you are probably that fan who sits on his couch and waits for a goal,a mazy dribble,a crunching challenge that makes the opponent go down like a pack of cards.
    Reply
  • 14 May 2012 3:45 PM

    Re: Season Overview: 5 players who shined and 5 who let us down

    It is about the team if the players win then its together or loose together, there were players that done more than others but some cant be let downs, like giggs wasnt that bad always has some assists or makes an impact like scoring against Norwich, like nani was good at the start of the season and helped the team then valenica kind of took his place and was better, hernandez still scored a few goals, he wasnt as good as last season but maybe everyone expected to much of him after a great first year and had more injuries so thats hardly his fault, even berbatov he hardly played but still got 9 goals and player of the month for december still helped the team, but being told you can leave cause you have no place in the squad no more your not going to be really motivated, owen either injured or just cant get in the team because competition is high.So they all helped in some way but other players outshine others, we have a big squad and not every player can play so its like some players will be leaving because there not good enough to play all the time , so i dont really say players let us down just not as good as the better ones if Berbatov, Owen,Park, Anderson leave its because we dont need them anymore.
    Reply
  • 14 May 2012 2:44 PM

    Re: Season Overview: 5 players who shined and 5 who let us down

    Gregory--roy:
    I just wanted to know which players made ​​a good impression and who disappoint us this crazy season....Thoughts??? For me: 5 who SHINED-->Rooney,A.Valencia,Carrick,Evans,Young 5 who LET US DOWN-->Evra,Nani,Chicharito,Giggs,FERGIE
    For me the 5 players who shined were Rooney, Valencia, Welbeck, Hernandez, Young 4 players who let us down were Rafael, Park, Giggs, Berbatov
    Reply
  • 13 May 2012 8:06 PM

    Re: Season Overview: 5 players who shined and 5 who let us down

    5 that shined: with out a doubt Rooney, Paul Scholes, Evans, Valencia and Young. 5 that let us down: Berbatov, Owens, Rio, Rafael and Hernandes Where was the chemistry and creativity between Rooney and Hernandes when they played. Welbeck has better pace and is more physical than Hernandes and and Owen combined!
    Reply
  • 13 May 2012 7:52 PM

    Re: Season Overview: 5 players who shined and 5 who let us down

    5 who shined: Evans, De gea, Rooney, Valencia & Carrick. 5 who let us down: Rafa, Giggs (Cant blame him, getting old and much faster game), Hernandez & Ji. Dont really have a 5th, I disagree with Evra as he has performed well quite often but agreed he has made mistakes.
    Reply
  • 13 May 2012 7:47 PM

    Re: Season Overview: 5 players who shined and 5 who let us down

    akulaII:
    Fergie let us down with his favouritism and poor selections..... I thot the defenders did ok given the absence of Vidic, our attack was poor but not shambolic, however the midfield is DIABOLICAL ... What exactly is the purpose of Carrick, he can tackle, he can't make a for ward pass, he can't content an aerial ball.... Boy, i missed Fletcher and Ando I hope for a better next year. Please buy us a defensive and a creative midfield ...and bring back Quieroz as chief coach, he is out of work anyway

    Are you actually saying you didn't see the purpose of Carrick, our best midfilelder this season?

    Reply
  • 13 May 2012 7:43 PM

    Re: Season Overview: 5 players who shined and 5 who let us down

    You include the great SAF as a player? If it wern't for SAF we wouldn't be the club we are now. Your a disgrace!!
    LOVE YOU SIR ALEX!!
    Reply
Page 3 of 4 (57 items) < Previous 1 2 3 4 Next >