The views expressed on this noticeboard are expressed by the fans themselves and do not necessarily reflect the views of Manchester United or any of its representatives. The viewing and posting of messages on this noticeboard is subject to the Forum Terms, which can be viewed here.
Sign in | Join | Help
Faq
Contact Us
Sort Posts:
Previous Next
Manchester United Community » ManUtd.com » Transfer Speculation » One more DEPARTURE and our squad will become the BEST !
  • 20 Aug 2012 8:25 PM

    Re: One more DEPARTURE and our squad will become the BEST !

    is selling him a must for united? yes it is.even ONE mistake can be critical.imagine just one extra 2 points last season(a win instead of a draw).what would happen ? a weak shaky uncertain low level defender with no future and particular ability.instead of that the club can replace a veteran and not expensive one.(for the bench).the main deference between united and arsenal is the caliber of players .the quality of evans? may be OK ! and guess what this (may be OK) quality can do to a team who wants revenge (who is chasing CITY sheikhs !) my point is ,its quite possible that we have not got ferdinand and vidic for a big part of the season.what happened and what achieved last season with evans? i changed my mind and i am not going to upload any collection of his errors on youtube ,cause i am a real fan of the club,but by just watching random highlights of the last season you can UNDERSTAND what is waiting for us with a jonny evans at our back lines.i am not a hooligan who swear others or shout,if you disagree with me about evans,Ok.just wait and see him against Tevez and Dzeko or even against normal PL attackers.judge him.i am not exaggerating anything so i am sure he will prove my points asap.i just sincerely wish he doesnt cost us the title...
    Reply
  • 20 Aug 2012 7:12 PM

    Re: One more DEPARTURE and our squad will become the BEST !

    Ok I agree with you that Evans is nowhere near the class of Ferdinand and Vidic. But by us selling him how does this complete us. I can't understand esp when u say Ferdinand and Vidic are injury prone. That is more reason to keep him. Thank God u not the manager. But please explain me by us selling him how does this make us the Best
    Reply
  • 20 Aug 2012 6:23 PM
    • joxo
    • Not Ranked
    • Joined on 5 Feb 2012
    • Posts 263

    Re: One more DEPARTURE and our squad will become the BEST !

    Anderson is the one who should depart. Starting on the bench today, which will probably be a common feature for him this season, if he's not sold.
    Reply
  • 20 Aug 2012 6:13 PM

    Re: One more DEPARTURE and our squad will become the BEST !

    Libra-o-Rabbit:
    I am pretty sure all of you guys will be ashamed of how you are supporting him now
    Your love makes us stronger
    Your hate makes us unstoppable
    Reply
  • 20 Aug 2012 6:06 PM

    Re: One more DEPARTURE and our squad will become the BEST !

    I am pretty sure all of you guys will be ashamed of how you are supporting him now.Just judge him without any prejudice .I didnt say drop him because he raped a teenager years ago,i say focus on his error,focus on how we lose points and confidence because of a shaky defender at the back and focus on how can't we say we are safe when he is playing.the possibility of a dangerous opponent free kick is too high with him.and ,NO ! I dont have any other account.what's wrong with 21 posts since 2009?and what 's the point in having many accounts? do they give the members financial benefits for the amount of accounts? I check all the news online since i became a fan back in 1995 ! of course i will be happy if this jonny evans scores 3 goals per game and help the team keep clean sheets ,but thing is HE JUST CANT.HE IS NOT AS HIGH CLASS AS THE OTHERS ,AND HE IS GOING TO COST US POINTS.wait and see.another lost title for us because of showing nonsense support for a nonsense crappy defender.wait and see,wait and see.WAIT AND SEE.and...be sure i am not shouting.it's just a caps lock.plz just wait and see. smiley face : )
    Reply
  • 20 Aug 2012 6:06 PM

    Re: One more DEPARTURE and our squad will become the BEST !

    Libra-o-Rabbit:
    maybe Vidic.be sure we can not use ferdinand for more than 10 games this season.the two veterans are injury prone and out of the line for months like the last year.(ferdinand is out already and vidic will join him soon
    *** please Vidic is the best CB in the world...and he is not injury prone...he just had bad luck next season/....this should be one of the most stupid post i have read...i am surprised it is not reported by any one :/
    Your love makes us stronger
    Your hate makes us unstoppable
    Reply
  • 20 Aug 2012 6:05 PM

    Re: One more DEPARTURE and our squad will become the BEST !

    Taz153:
    I think arrivals make you stronger not departures. We need to sign one more player. In : Dembele or M'Vila. Out : Berbatov
    SIgh, I really hate telepathy sometimes.
    It's so simple to be wise; think of something stupid to say and don't say it
    Reply
  • 20 Aug 2012 6:01 PM

    Re: One more DEPARTURE and our squad will become the BEST !

    I think arrivals make you stronger not departures. We need to sign one more player. In : Dembele or M'Vila. Out : Berbatov
    what is love? Manchester United is love
    Reply
  • 20 Aug 2012 6:01 PM

    Re: One more DEPARTURE and our squad will become the BEST !

    Evans arguably our best centre back last season he even shocked me with the consistency in his performances hopefully hell have another good campaign but I can only imagine Vidic If stay fit to be our best defender by a long mile
    GGMU
    Reply
  • 20 Aug 2012 5:55 PM

    Re: One more DEPARTURE and our squad will become the BEST !

    madhouse:
    Libra-o-Rabbit:
    Good ! so lets be patient and analyze his performances after each game.this post will be updated ! i am sure he will prove his self asap.count the missed points....
    You have had your two minutes of fame Rabbit. Please go back into your hole.

    Actually, 21 posts since 2009? You have multiple accounts, don't you? Just created this nonsense from a different one. sigh...

    Well said Madhouse. You are definitely right on the multiple accounts, this guy my guess is a wind up merchant who keeps getting blocked so changes his profile.
    there are no city fans only united haters
    Reply
  • 20 Aug 2012 5:22 PM

    Re: One more DEPARTURE and our squad will become the BEST !

    Libra-o-Rabbit:
    Good ! so lets be patient and analyze his performances after each game.this post will be updated ! i am sure he will prove his self asap.count the missed points....
    You have had your two minutes of fame Rabbit. Please go back into your hole.

    Actually, 21 posts since 2009? You have multiple accounts, don't you? Just created this nonsense from a different one. sigh...

    My greatest challenge is not whats happening at the moment my greatest challenge was knocking Liverpool right off their *** perch
    And you can print that
    Reply
  • 20 Aug 2012 5:21 PM

    Re: One more DEPARTURE and our squad will become the BEST !

    Libra-o-Rabbit:
    supporting a normal player in a lovely united red shirt is an act of gentle and greatness.but isn't it too much ? ok,lets talk about exact examples.let's compare Evans with our other defenders: is he better than Smalling? or Jones? or Vidic? or Ferdinand? or even Carrick playing the role ? what about our rivals.is he better than Skrtel ? Agger? Carragher ? Can we even compare him with Terry? Ivanovic? Alex? Kompany ? or aboard ones ... Lucio?Pepe?Poyul? or..... what am i saying? i am saying HE IS NOTHING LIKE A WORLD CLASS CHOICE .i suppose all the fans agree,just check the suggestions for the XI this season.NO ONE mentions him.the second thing..is he a really B CLASS defender for manchester united bench ? how can you be that cruel,comparing someone like chicharito with evans? a simple error by a CB will cost a game.a total Cup maybe.how much has he improved through these years.say since 2007-2008 till now? is he even better than Wes Brown or O'shea (our former two CB's).about the last season's performances.or generally his games.Can he even make a play ? can he cross a simple ball ? can he stop a long ball? can't you really remember how much we suffered because of his nonsense penalties or free kicks given to opponents?why he was playing?because of hilarious injuries of other players.did he deserve a place ? of course not ! there was simply no other choice.and we didnt achieve anything by his presence.we just didnt lost all the games 6-1 because of others abilities.he didnt add anything special to the squad.
    Evans is 3rd choice center back behind Vidic and Rio simple as that. Smalling and Jones are still inexperienced which is why Evans is picked ahead of them at center back. This has nothing to do with Rival center backs at all. Comparing Evans and Kompany is like comparing Vidic and Savic. Actually thats an insult to Jonny. Point is Evans is 3rd choice nobody is denying that I am just saying he is a quality player to have as back up. Just because he is not a big name and made a few mistakes you are immediately discounting him, its pathetic.
    Reply
  • 20 Aug 2012 5:17 PM

    Re: One more DEPARTURE and our squad will become the BEST !

    Good ! so lets be patient and analyze his performances after each game.this post will be updated ! i am sure he will prove his self asap.count the missed points....
    Reply
  • 20 Aug 2012 4:37 PM

    Re: One more DEPARTURE and our squad will become the BEST !

    Libra-o-Rabbit:
    supporting a normal player in a lovely united red shirt is an act of gentle and greatness.but isn't it too much ? ok,lets talk about exact examples.let's compare Evans with our other defenders: is he better than Smalling? or Jones? or Vidic? or Ferdinand? or even Carrick playing the role ? what about our rivals.is he better than Skrtel ? Agger? Carragher ? Can we even compare him with Terry? Ivanovic? Alex? Kompany ? or aboard ones ... Lucio?Pepe?Poyul? or..... what am i saying? i am saying HE IS NOTHING LIKE A WORLD CLASS CHOICE
    Lol, at this point I think you're trying to look stupid. Here's how I rate them, only my opinion, but I think a lot of people would agre

    Evans = smalling

    Evans better than jones (jones is younger and will be the better player eventually though)

    vidic better EVERYONE! (seriously, a centreback half as good as vida would still be world class! Nothing wrong with not being as good as him)

    Evans = Ferdinand (he's not the player he once was, still very good though)

    Evans better than carrick as cb (Im a big fan of carrick, but he's only good enough at cb for emergencies)

    Evans better than skrtel

    Evans = agger

    Evans WAY BETTER THAN carragher (SERIOUSLY!? The guys been $hite for years!)

    Evans = terry (terry was f***ing $hite last season, think he'll be better this year though)

    ivanovic better than Evans

    Evans better than Alex

    kompany better than Evans (like vidic, kompany is brilliant, nothing wrong with not being that good)

    Evans = lucio (see Ferdinand)

    Evans better than pepe

    Evans = puyol (see Ferdinand)

    Talking Reds; proving that common sense isn't that common
    Reply
  • 20 Aug 2012 4:32 PM

    Re: One more DEPARTURE and our squad will become the BEST !

    Evans proved last season that he is a very good player, he's improved alot from the season before last and he will keep improving as he gains more experience. I think he is our 3rd choice CB at the moment behind Vidic and Ferdinand.
    Fail to prepare Prepare to fail
    Reply
Page 1 of 3 (35 items) 1 2 3 Next >