This seemed to be a thread worth keeping alive a little longer because the Old Trafford atmosphere is a subject that crops up more and more.
I used to stand on the United Road terraces and revel in the great stereophonic effect of the Stretford End and K Stand in full voice - unbelievable. The frightening thing is that it wasn't that long ago, yet when I get to OT today it seems like a distant memory of a bygone halycon age.
When I question (to myself) why the atmosphere has changed so much I immediately think about the "all-seater" impact but then this is no different in other Premier League grounds so it does not explain things entirely.
What I do think is significant is the commercial impact of United's success over the last 20 or so years. Today, for me, Old Trafford "smells" corporate and commercial. I acknowledge the positives that money has brought the club and I do understand the pressures that come with the need to generate cash to survive by wringing every penny out of anything that can yield revenue. Of course the effect has been to spread the reach of the club to every corner of the globe.
We sometimes debate on here what we call "gloryhunters" as though they have latched on to the club because of its success but I wonder whether it is actually the other way round - i.e. the club has (in competition with the likes of Real Madrid, Barcelona, Liverpool, Chelsea etc.) gone out to "snare" people as supporters. Once hooked they naturally want to attend Old Trafford and savour what it means to be at a game within the Theatre of Dreams but they have no cultural awareness of the fact that their presence demands proactivity rather reactivity. How could they know this perhaps?
Who knows what proportion of the ground is made up of people in this category at any given game, but if United's global support is over 100m it has to be significant.
Added to this the ever-increasing cost of attending games (incl. cup schemes etc.) for regulars and there will inevitably be games that regulars will sacrifice for economic reasons - the ones that appear less significant in the great scheme of things.
With the advent of the ticket exchange in come the wider cohorts of supporter (fully entitled as members to be) and what do you have? A fragmented stadium with far less concentrated and proactive support than we had in the days of sardine-packed "pie and bovril" terraces, occasional bursts of song from one part of the ground that quickly fade and die and brief celebratory commotion after a United goal.
And who do I blame? Well actually not supporters nor in fact the club but the headlong plunge of football into a commercial armageddon.