For long term Aguero / just for 2-4 yrs Villa

both

Niether, our weakness lies in the midfield.  De Rossi anyone?

Suarez! Young and a proven goalscorer/provider at domestic and international level. Villa is too old and Aguero is overhyped.

Villa, he already said he prefers us instead of Chelsea, while aguero said he prefers chelsea rather than us. Rather have a player that wants to play for our team. Plus, Hopefully he can have the same impact has Torres if we do sign him.

Villa!

It doesn't matter.This whole thing is pointless.Fergie won't buy either.It's a waste of time discussing this.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 

David Villa for me.

I know he's not one of your options but I'd honestly think we'd be much better off with the likes of Huntelaar.

stupid question-villa by absolutely miles.far better finisher,lot more of a team player,can score from free kicks,can take corners,and hes not a money grabbing little pr*ck like sergio "200k a week please" aguero.forget the fact hes 27,hes got plenty left in the tank,at least another 100 goals.plus aguero is ridiculously overrated

i for one would be more comfortable with Villa though Aguero is equally good. If wishes were horses,I would love both of them in our squad!!!!!

UNITED  TILL  DEATH  DO  US  PART!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 I think both strikrs are brilliant but if i had to pick i would go for Villa every time hes a goalscorer its simple as that and thats what we need right now a goalscorer.I think Villa would be a perfect signing for is.I know many people question his gae and all that but why? hes only 27 years old its not that old and has many goo dyears ahead of him hes the striker that we need.With Valencia in desperate need of some cash i think we can get Villa for 30-35million and his team mate Silva for another 20-25million.In my opinion these two are a must but in Villa we would have a striker that can score 30 goals a season thats what we need.I know we have Rooney Owen Berbatov etc but tey wont get anywhere near 30 goals and with them alot setting up and creating chances Villa will bang them in.

Villa's goalscoring record all throughout his career has been very impressive.I do like Aguero aswell hes one of the best youngsters in the world but for me id go for Villa i just think hes a better goalscorer i see Aguero abit like Rooney.

I watch the Spanish League and I believe there is no comparison, Villa by far better than Aguero in terms of passing accuracy, threat on goal, and ability to scape from any defender.

Aguero is superb when there is no man to man way of defending. He is not EPL type of players

 defintley villa, ive seen aguero in some matches and i dont really think he's that special tbh :/

Either would add their own strengths to an already strong United squad. But I wouldn't go for either. Robin Van Persie would be my choice. Awesome player and proven in the Premier League.

Unfortunately Arsenal would not want to lose him and he seems to be a Gunner through and through. Shame, as he is a class player.