The views expressed on this noticeboard are expressed by the fans themselves and do not necessarily reflect the views of Manchester United or any of its representatives. The viewing and posting of messages on this noticeboard is subject to the Forum Terms, which can be viewed here.
Faq
Contact Us
Sort Posts:
Previous Next
  • 3 Nov 2009 8:29 AM

    Re: Out of the Man Utd & Arsenal Squads - Pick your best 11 - Debate.

                           Van der Saar

      Brown/Oshea    Ferdinand    Vidic    Evra

                  Anderson   Fletcher    

    Arshavin                               Rooney

                Berbatov   Van Persie

     

    Rooney is better used in midfield than a centre forward in my views.

     

    Our defence is the best in the League...i think Brown is better than Sagna

    Anderson + Fletcher is the best midfiel pairing unless we get Hargreaves back then it will be Anderson + Hargreaves. There is no way Fabregas will get on my team

    Berbatov + Van Persie = GOALS GOALS GOALS!.

     

     

    Manchester United 4 life!
    Reply
  • 3 Nov 2009 2:22 AM

    Re: Out of the Man Utd & Arsenal Squads - Pick your best 11 - Debate.

                                        Van Der Saar

    Sagna                     Vermaelan        Vidic          Evra

    Arshavin                  Hargreaves       Fabregas     Nasri

                                 Rooney             Van Persie

     

    I know most won't agree with Nasri over Giggs but hey ho it's all about opinions

    Reply
  • 2 Nov 2009 11:38 PM

    Re: Out of the Man Utd & Arsenal Squads - Pick your best 11 - Debate.

    PumpinDaddy:

      VDS

     Sagna Vidic Vermaelan Evra

                  Hargreaves

         Fletcher

                            Fabregas

    Van Persie                  Arshavin

                      Rooney

     

     

    Hard to disagree with this itYes would be a dream teamBig Smile

     
    Reply
  • 2 Nov 2009 11:02 PM

    Re: Out of the Man Utd & Arsenal Squads - Pick your best 11 - Debate.

                        VDS

     Sagna Vidic Vermaelan Evra

                  Hargreaves

         Fletcher

                            Fabregas

    Van Persie                  Arshavin

                      Rooney

    I dont usually like Rooney up frount alone but Van persie could join him with Hargreaves goin to the right or whatever.

    Its hard to leave Giggs out on current form too.

    It would aso be intresting to see this done with Chelseas team and Citys. Liverpools would be pointless obviously as 2 of their players would make it in.

    Reply
  • 2 Nov 2009 10:56 PM

    Re: Out of the Man Utd & Arsenal Squads - Pick your best 11 - Debate.

    redirish

    Thanks. When in doubt, one can always count on Giggs. I believe that Valencia too would be fine in your choices but at the moment he seems too....  predictable like one other has said before (i don't remember his name forgive me). Last Saturday's match Valencia showed some variation in his attacks so he will learn and grow in time.

    Reply
  • 2 Nov 2009 10:38 PM

    Re: Out of the Man Utd & Arsenal Squads - Pick your best 11 - Debate.

    Dont get me started !

    Yeah Hargreaves would be a dream beside Fabregas would'nt he a rock beside possibly the best playmaker in the world.

     

    Josie !

    It is tough enough is'nt it, actually when you knuckle down to pick it, thats why i changed it & went for Giggs, well spotted !

     

    I was going to pick another team but i said Arsenal would be the hardest so went for that, i think alot of people on this thread will come up with a 6-5 which would be more or less a 50-50 pick from both teams.

    Reply
  • 2 Nov 2009 10:30 PM

    Re: Out of the Man Utd & Arsenal Squads - Pick your best 11 - Debate.

    Matt Cornejo:

    Very difficult.

    I wonder, up until this year, whom the pick would be in central midfield.  Fletcher does deserve to be there now.

    Fletcher has earned that place this season, your right, last season we were'nt exactly blessed in that area id put Arshavin in the middle with Fabregas & Rosicky on the right. That would've been at the start of last season, but we all know how Fletcherinho came on as the season progressed so he has that position now, for me anyways !

     

    Reply
  • 2 Nov 2009 10:28 PM

    Re: Out of the Man Utd & Arsenal Squads - Pick your best 11 - Debate.

    Hehe I'll go ahead and be conservative. I believed you picked Ryan Giggs. Simply because he has more experience and has been consistant so far this season.

    Reply
  • 2 Nov 2009 10:26 PM

    Re: Out of the Man Utd & Arsenal Squads - Pick your best 11 - Debate.

     

                                                                       1.
                                                               Van der Sar

                                3.                  2.                                    3.                  4.                                  
                            Sagna             Vidic                            Vermaelan          Evra

                                 6.                  7.                                   8.                           9.
                             Arshavin          Fabregas                    Hargreaves(when fit)  Giggs

     

                                                     10.                                 11.      
                                                  Rooney                         Van Persie

     I agree with you Red Irish for the most part of this squad, tbh this is a very good squad.

    Reply
  • 2 Nov 2009 10:22 PM

    Re: Out of the Man Utd & Arsenal Squads - Pick your best 11 - Debate.

    Very difficult.

    I wonder, up until this year, whom the pick would be in central midfield.  Fletcher does deserve to be there now.

    Reply
  • 2 Nov 2009 10:15 PM

    Re: Out of the Man Utd & Arsenal Squads - Pick your best 11 - Debate.

    Josie17:

    Valencia is an interesting pick. Why?

    I changed it there, its actually hard enough to pick it, Try it !

    Reply
  • 2 Nov 2009 10:10 PM

    Re: Out of the Man Utd & Arsenal Squads - Pick your best 11 - Debate.

    Valencia is an interesting pick. Why?

    Reply
  • 2 Nov 2009 10:07 PM

    Re: Out of the Man Utd & Arsenal Squads - Pick your best 11 - Debate.

    I love this thread....Aren't you on a roll today?
    Not everyone will agree with me....But I don't care!

                                           Van Der Saar

    Sagna              Vidic                    Ferdinand (when fit)            Evra

    Arshavin             Fabregas               Carrick                      Giggs
    (because I say so)

                             Rooney                Berbatov

    Reply
  • 2 Nov 2009 9:59 PM

    Out of the Man Utd & Arsenal Squads - Pick your best 11 - Debate.

    I thought this might be interesting to see what team fans on here line out & the reasons for their selection. Heres mine.....

     

                                                                       1.
                                                               Van der Saar

                                3.                  2.                                    3.                  4.                                  
                            Sagna             Vidic                            Vermaelan          Evra

                                 6.                  7.                                      8.                   9.
                             Arhavin          Fabregas                         Fletcher           Giggs

     

                                                     10.                                 11.      
                                                  Rooney                         Van Persie

     

    The reason i chose Vermalaen was he has impressed me alot so far this season, he hit the ground running & adapted to the PL real well, as well as his defensive qualities he also scores, from what i've seen of him he is a grafter & i like them type players, a real bargain for £10 million  

    Sagna a powerfull right back that rarely loses out, another grafter.

    Fabregas, Do i need to explain why i chose him !!

    Van Persie, this was the hardest choice, I chose him cause of his consistancy & the fact i think he would work a dream along side Rooney as he is a busy player thats constantly looking for the ball, he's also a great finisher.

    Arshavin, another lad that took to the PL as soon as he came into it, a constant threat & a class winger, along with Fabregas Id love to see this lad in a United Jersey. 

     

    Reply
Page 2 of 2 (29 items) < Previous 1 2