The views expressed on this noticeboard are expressed by the fans themselves and do not necessarily reflect the views of Manchester United or any of its representatives. The viewing and posting of messages on this noticeboard is subject to the Forum Terms, which can be viewed here.
Faq
Contact Us
Sort Posts:
Previous Next
  • 7 Nov 2009 8:25 PM

    Re: How many players we have that are the best at their positions?

    4-3-3 formation

    GK: Casillas (Real Madrid)

    RB: Maicon (Inter)

    RCB: Puyol/Terry (Barcelona/Chelsea)

    LCB: Vidic (MAN UNITED)

    LB: Evra (MAN UNITED)

    DM: Essien (Chelsea)

    RCM: Xavi (Barcelona)

    LCM: Iniesta (Barcelona)

    RWF: Messi (Barcelona)

    ST: Drogba/Torres (Chelsea/Liverpool)

    LWF: C Ronaldo (Real Madrid)

    Reply
  • 7 Nov 2009 6:55 PM

    Re: How many players we have that are the best at their positions?

    HM2K7:

    incognito:
    Personally, I would back Ferdi as the best CB in the world based on technique and skill up to 2 years ago. Now, due to injury and fitness it wouldn't be fair at all to put Ferdi there. There's no CB better than Nesta when he's on form, and right now he's on form. None comes close.
     

    I disagree on the Nesta part but hey it's a forum, it's all good.

    Might as well put mine in as long as I'm here, by the way this isn't a s starting XI it's just my opinion on who's the best in each position.

    GK: Casillas
    CB: Vidic
    RB: Maicon
    LB: Evra
    DM: Essien
    CM:Xavi
    AM: Gerrard
    RM/W: Messi
    LM/W: Ronaldo
    F(Man behind the out and out striker):  Rooney
    CF(Out and out striker): Torres

     

    ahhhhhhhh i like that, the 4-3-3 formation. and with a line up like that itd be unstoppable. disagree with torres but everyone else i can agree with. the out and out striker for me would have to Villa or Pirlo. brilliant those two. non stop workers. and they dont pout about and comlain to the ref all the time like torres ( if you want to know why i disagree with torres go read my first comment on page 1)

    Reply
  • 7 Nov 2009 6:52 PM

    Re: How many players we have that are the best at their positions?

    JR_Lewis:

    i would say 2 for sure maybe 3

    evra best left back in the world

    vidic best center back in the world

    and maybe rooney as one of the best center forwards to play with an out an out striker

     

    3 to be honest isn't enough to win ya the champions league, if ya look at barca and other big clubs they have 4-5 + 

     

    i would honestly love to know how other clubs have 4 or 5 "best players in their position" please explain that to me becuz what you just said and what the guy is asking just inst clicking right. becuz if other clubs had 4 or 5 best players in their posititon. how would another club have 4 or 5 players of the best position if the other club already had the players for that best position.

    Reply
  • 7 Nov 2009 4:49 PM

    Re: How many players we have that are the best at their positions?

    i would say 2 for sure maybe 3

    evra best left back in the world

    vidic best center back in the world

    and maybe rooney as one of the best center forwards to play with an out an out striker

     

    3 to be honest isn't enough to win ya the champions league, if ya look at barca and other big clubs they have 4-5 + 

    Reply
  • 7 Nov 2009 4:20 PM

    Re: How many players we have that are the best at their positions?

    incognito:
    Personally, I would back Ferdi as the best CB in the world based on technique and skill up to 2 years ago. Now, due to injury and fitness it wouldn't be fair at all to put Ferdi there. There's no CB better than Nesta when he's on form, and right now he's on form. None comes close.
     

    I disagree on the Nesta part but hey it's a forum, it's all good.

    Might as well put mine in as long as I'm here, by the way this isn't a s starting XI it's just my opinion on who's the best in each position.

    GK: Casillas
    CB: Vidic
    RB: Maicon
    LB: Evra
    DM: Essien
    CM:Xavi
    AM: Gerrard
    RM/W: Messi
    LM/W: Ronaldo
    F(Man behind the out and out striker):  Rooney
    CF(Out and out striker): Torres

    Sure youre entitled to your opinion its just that your opinion is stupid

    RIP Robert Enke
    Reply
  • 7 Nov 2009 3:00 PM

    Re: How many players we have that are the best at their positions?

    HM2K7:

    JIVARA:
    centre back with vidic= nesta
     

    I agree with most of the others but Nesta? Honestly there are much better CB's out there, Puyol, Chiellini, Terry even Pique is better than Nesta, let alone Ferdinand, they guy's just having a bad run of games. it happens.

    Personally, I would back Ferdi as the best CB in the world based on technique and skill up to 2 years ago. Now, due to injury and fitness it wouldn't be fair at all to put Ferdi there. There's no CB better than Nesta when he's on form, and right now he's on form. None comes close.

    Original Username : Ohh Its Off The Woodwork
    Reply
  • 7 Nov 2009 1:41 PM

    Re: How many players we have that are the best at their positions?

    JIVARA:
    centre back with vidic= nesta
     

    I agree with most of the others but Nesta? Honestly there are much better CB's out there, Puyol, Chiellini, Terry even Pique is better than Nesta, let alone Ferdinand, they guy's just having a bad run of games. it happens.

    Sure youre entitled to your opinion its just that your opinion is stupid

    RIP Robert Enke
    Reply
  • 7 Nov 2009 1:40 PM

    Re: How many players we have that are the best at their positions?

    Unfortunately, only one - Pat Evra! Ando has the potential, Kiko is also looking good for the future.
    Reply
  • 7 Nov 2009 1:29 PM

    Re: How many players we have that are the best at their positions?

    red irish:

    How many players do we have that are best in their positions?

    I reckon we have 2 Vidic & Evra. 

     

    1. Buffon - Juventus
    2. Maicon - Inter
    3. Chiellini - Juventus
    4. Vidic - United
    5. Evra - United
    6. Essien - Chelsea
    7. Xavi - Barcelona
    8. Iniesta - Barcelona
    9. Ronaldo - Real Madrid
    10. Messi - Barcelona
    11. Torres - Liverpool
     

     

    Beer i'd say Nesta over Cheillini though, but pretty spot on.

    4-3-3

    Original Username : Ohh Its Off The Woodwork
    Reply
  • 7 Nov 2009 1:20 PM

    Re: How many players we have that are the best at their positions?

    How many players do we have that are best in their positions?

    I reckon we have 2 Vidic & Evra. 

     

    1. Buffon - Juventus
    2. Maicon - Inter
    3. Chiellini - Juventus
    4. Vidic - United
    5. Evra - United
    6. Essien - Chelsea
    7. Xavi - Barcelona
    8. Iniesta - Barcelona
    9. Ronaldo - Real Madrid
    10. Messi - Barcelona
    11. Torres - Liverpool
     

    Reply
  • 7 Nov 2009 12:39 PM

    Re: How many players we have that are the best at their positions?

    G.Norris18:

    incognito:
    both Ronaldo and Ribery are preferred on the left wing, and it goes wthout saying that Ronnie owns that wing. While Messi owns the right.
     

    fair play... this is off topic; but "incognito" was the name of the team i played with when i did my ankle in. hope thats not a sign of some sort Tongue Tied

     

    Hah, well if it's comforting in anyway, the screen name wasn't inspired by a football team Stick out tongue

    Original Username : Ohh Its Off The Woodwork
    Reply
  • 7 Nov 2009 11:44 AM

    Re: How many players we have that are the best at their positions?

     goalkeeper - casillas

    centre back - vidic

    left back - evra

    centre midfield - iniesta

    left midfield - ronaldo

    right centre midfield - lampard

    right midfield - messi

     

     

    as for strikers i think rooney, torress, drogba, villa are the best.

    what cha say!
    Reply
  • 7 Nov 2009 11:37 AM

    Re: How many players we have that are the best at their positions?

    Buffon (GK), Maicon (CB), Evra (CB), Vidic (CB), Ferdinand (CB), Hargreaves (DMF), Lampard (CMF), Iniesta (AMF), Ronaldo (LWG), Messi (RWG), Drogba (CF).

    I'd love to put Rooney in at AMF, but, as he wants to play CF, no can do. I hate Drogba, but when he is on form he is incredible.

    With Silva and Villa in the team we could look very good indeed.

    VDS, Rafael, Evra, Vidic, Ferdinand, Hargreaves, Fletcher, Rooney, Silva, Valencia/Nani, Villa

    Reply
  • 7 Nov 2009 11:00 AM

    Re: How many players we have that are the best at their positions?

     Keeper - Cassi

    Cb - Vidic / Pique

    Rb - Maicon

    Lb - Evra 

    Rm - Ronaldo

    Lm - Ribery

    Cm - Gerrard / Iniesta

    Supporting striker - Messi

    Striker - Torres

    Reply
  • 7 Nov 2009 9:32 AM

    Re: How many players we have that are the best at their positions?

    How many players we have that are the best at their positions?

    3.

    Van Der Sar,Vidic and Evra.

    Reply
Page 2 of 3 (41 items) < Previous 1 2 3 Next >