warrenoliver:

I will be MAN UTD TILL I DIE but really the squad playing now is nowhere near the best United could put up. We seriously need better defenders, and the only striker worth something at the moment is faithful Wayne Rooney. Owen is an over rated Liverpool reject thats my view, Carrick clearly is not the best out there and is very inconsistent, Nani is well only one word SHITE, O'Shae is only lucky to still be wearing the RED honor, Brown is doing a bit better as he is not letting so many balls through any more, we seriously need to get better defenders, strikers and 1 or 2 midfielders. The only proper players there at the mo is

GIGGS

ROONEY

SCHOLES

FERDINAND when he wants to

EVRA can hold it well, but he is not top of the league

and the new guys better settle and start showing themselves time waits for no man

 Well I guess Im gonna get some flack of this but hey so be it I have spoken my mind

make me laugh...  hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

warrenoliver:

I will be MAN UTD TILL I DIE but really the squad playing now is nowhere near the best United could put up. We seriously need better defenders, and the only striker worth something at the moment is faithful Wayne Rooney. Owen is an over rated Liverpool reject thats my view, Carrick clearly is not the best out there and is very inconsistent, Nani is well only one word SHITE, O'Shae is only lucky to still be wearing the RED honor, Brown is doing a bit better as he is not letting so many balls through any more, we seriously need to get better defenders, strikers and 1 or 2 midfielders. The only proper players there at the mo is

GIGGS

ROONEY

SCHOLES

FERDINAND when he wants to

EVRA can hold it well, but he is not top of the league

and the new guys better settle and start showing themselves time waits for no man

 Well I guess Im gonna get some flack of this but hey so be it I have spoken my mind

make me laugh...  hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

I will be MAN UTD TILL I DIE but really the squad playing now is nowhere near the best United could put up. We seriously need better defenders, and the only striker worth something at the moment is faithful Wayne Rooney. Owen is an over rated Liverpool reject thats my view, Carrick clearly is not the best out there and is very inconsistent, Nani is well only one word SHITE, O'Shae is only lucky to still be wearing the RED honor, Brown is doing a bit better as he is not letting so many balls through any more, we seriously need to get better defenders, strikers and 1 or 2 midfielders. The only proper players there at the mo is

GIGGS

ROONEY

SCHOLES

FERDINAND when he wants to

EVRA can hold it well, but he is not top of the league

and the new guys better settle and start showing themselves time waits for no man

 Well I guess Im gonna get some flack of this but hey so be it I have spoken my mind

Djemba-Djemba, Kleberson and Taibi are the worst of the worst.

I think fergies's worst signing were Tiabi, Djemba, Kleberson, Veron, Poborsky, Prunier???? (I think that was his name, he was a bald french dude from lyon or marsielle, i think, he was lame anyway), Nani, Bosnich, Carroll and Jordi Cruyff

There is a difference between bad player and those not fitting in. Veron and Forlan are/were great players outside of OT so can't simply say they are bad signing, they simply don't fit in. In my memory Klberson was a high profile signing that never took off, and don't think he has done anything great post OT era (unlike Forlan or Djemba). Nani can potentially become a bad signing only because of the price tag on him, as he did score a few key goals for us in previous seasons.

p.s. how come no-one mention Miller? I can hardly recall him playing a game outside of the League/FA cup games.

 Liam miller, was quite overrated, even hyped ast he future keano..Massimo taibi is wat makes me really laugh though...

fabian barthez.. is the most obvious one for me. i thought he was as bad as roy caroll

4-4-2:

Solomon Onilado:

 Nani is playing like an amputated dog at the moment, he should be up there if he don't up his performances NOTICEABLY. He probably won't so I'm going for Nani to be up there, as well as the usuals which goes without saying.

 

I am having difficulty visualising an amputated dog play football ................... so I quess I will just have to watch Nani....

Now look at that poor Nani.. I MEAN DOG, look at that poor dog! 

Stick him on a football pitch and he'll be lost and play just like Nani, like an amputated dog who plays like a 4 year old in the park with his daddy.

Of course I want Nani to prove me wrong, one person (who Red Yankee before and I totally finished, his comments were left to look clueless) said i'll have to eat my words like it's a bad thing!

In my opinion, Kleberson is without doubt SAF's worst signing.

Solomon Onilado:

 Nani is playing like an amputated dog at the moment, he should be up there if he don't up his performances NOTICEABLY. He probably won't so I'm going for Nani to be up there, as well as the usuals which goes without saying.

I am having difficulty visualising an amputated dog play football ................... so I quess I will just have to watch Nani....

Gavinio:

Gabranth:

 Why isn't Barthez on the list?

Because for much of his time at the club he did a good job in goal. 

Once again Logic triumphs Gav, lol.

Gabranth:

 Why isn't Barthez on the list?

Because for much of his time at the club he did a good job in goal. 

 I think of a few that have very bad

Bellion

Taibi

Miller

Veron

Kleberson

Djemba Djemba

Bosnich

Im sure there are many more i just carnt be bothered to go all through them.

 Why isn't Barthez on the list?