The views expressed on this noticeboard are expressed by the fans themselves and do not necessarily reflect the views of Manchester United or any of its representatives. The viewing and posting of messages on this noticeboard is subject to the Forum Terms, which can be viewed here.
Faq
Contact Us
Sort Posts:
Previous Next
  • 18 Mar 2012 6:14 PM

    Re: Time to move Rooney backwards.....

    F U C K N O
    Don`t hate on my opinion!
    Reply
  • 18 Mar 2012 12:05 PM

    Re: Time to move Rooney backwards.....

    jojo22:
    We have so many good looking options upfront now with Welbeck establishing himself this season and Chicharito sure to do better in his third season. I think we should move Rooney back into midfield now. He is getting older and has the experience to play the position. It would allow us to give Macheda more chances and if we sell berbatov we could sign another striker which I think would be easier and cheaper than signing an established or even a young potential playmaker. Sneijder or Modric would be very expensive and someone like Eriksen or Gotze again expensive. Maybe we could sign Llorente? What do you think?
    We are struggling at right and left back, should we play him there, or if De Gea has another little wobble maybe Wayne could put the gloves on. Why the hell would you want to put our most affective player further away from goal because we haven’t got the midfield players with enough quality to pick a pass? As for Danny and Chica,’ I hope we don’t have to find out how they’d get on without Rooney beside, because they are nowhere near ready to lead the line. And that’s not a criticism of either, it’s a fact!
    Reply
  • 18 Mar 2012 11:40 AM

    Re: Time to move Rooney backwards.....

    silvester:
    ownagemt:
    Rooney is good as the main man and the supporter. Only problem is we don't have a target man. Welbeck's okay for the role some games but he doesn't match up with Rooney all that much anymore. I'd much prefer to see Rooney as the spearhead with Giggs or Young in behind him. Of course it wouldn't be an issue if our manager didn't have a problem with our golden boot winner target man.
    Who needs a target man when Hernandez and Welbecak can do a good job there.Do we even play with 1.I mean alongs our strikers score goals it dosnt matter if we havent got a target man.In Hernandez and Owen we have 2 of the best finishers in the game Hernandez can only get better while Owen is a great role model.Welbeck is still young but hes improving all the time so his Macheda who i have high hopes for who can score goals while Roney can linke the play all together score and create goals.No need for another striker right now.
    It's not really that simple though is it? How many games have we been out possessed this season compared to last? We're constantly under pressure and do you wanna know why, oh simple one? It's because when we panic and shove long balls up, it's not going anywhere, it's going straight to the opposition. A targetman like Berba is more than just finishing, he's someone who will hold the ball up, Yakubu probably can't finish as well as Hernandez (though I think his finishing is overrated slightly) but Hernandez would never work at Blackburn.

    Zamora is widely praised for holding the ball up but who here can do it? Rooney? Sure but he's back defending, bringing me back to the idea he should be the spearhead. Welbeck has the touch and a decent amount of awareness but he's more of a run-behind-the-defence kind of guy, like Hernandez. Which, again, is good enough when we're doing well to satisfy people without a hint of analytical skills like you but when you look further into it, you do see a problem. We can't hold the ball up, we're either playing well or we're being dominated. There needs to be a middle ground and someone to take the pressure off (as I'm sure even the biggest Hernandez supporter will agree, Berbatov does this very well). Otherwise, as I said, we'll defend, the launch the ball up field to nothingness. Hernandez isn't going to win a standing header against a full back, Welbeck is slightly more likely but it's not his game set. Berbatov, Carrol, Yakubu will and all have the ability to keep the ball while the rest of the team shifts from defensive phase to possession phase to attacking phase. It's so simple, it evades me that even veterans of the forum like you can't see it.

    Reply
  • 18 Mar 2012 10:21 AM

    Re: Time to move Rooney backwards.....

    ownagemt:
    Rooney is good as the main man and the supporter. Only problem is we don't have a target man. Welbeck's okay for the role some games but he doesn't match up with Rooney all that much anymore. I'd much prefer to see Rooney as the spearhead with Giggs or Young in behind him. Of course it wouldn't be an issue if our manager didn't have a problem with our golden boot winner target man.
    Who needs a target man when Hernandez and Welbecak can do a good job there.Do we even play with 1.I mean alongs our strikers score goals it dosnt matter if we havent got a target man.In Hernandez and Owen we have 2 of the best finishers in the game Hernandez can only get better while Owen is a great role model.Welbeck is still young but hes improving all the time so his Macheda who i have high hopes for who can score goals while Roney can linke the play all together score and create goals.No need for another striker right now.
    Reply
  • 18 Mar 2012 10:17 AM

    Re: Time to move Rooney backwards.....

    silvester:
    89cruefan2:
    No thanks

    I would keep Rooney in the SS position he plays now

    Rooney has said its his prefered position, so why not just let him stay there.

    I agree man thats his best position where he can do the most damage linking the play between midfield and attack know what i mean.
    Just my point!
    Reply
  • 18 Mar 2012 10:14 AM

    Re: Time to move Rooney backwards.....

    Rooney is good as the main man and the supporter. Only problem is we don't have a target man. Welbeck's okay for the role some games but he doesn't match up with Rooney all that much anymore. I'd much prefer to see Rooney as the spearhead with Giggs or Young in behind him. Of course it wouldn't be an issue if our manager didn't have a problem with our golden boot winner target man.
    Reply
  • 18 Mar 2012 10:05 AM

    Re: Time to move Rooney backwards.....

    89cruefan2:
    No thanks

    I would keep Rooney in the SS position he plays now

    Rooney has said its his prefered position, so why not just let him stay there.

    I agree man thats his best position where he can do the most damage linking the play between midfield and attack know what i mean.
    Reply
  • 17 Mar 2012 8:10 PM

    Re: Time to move Rooney backwards.....

    No thanks

    I would keep Rooney in the SS position he plays now

    Rooney has said its his prefered position, so why not just let him stay there.

    I will fight until i die
    Reply
  • 17 Mar 2012 8:09 PM

    Re: Time to move Rooney backwards.....

    jojo22:
    We have so many good looking options upfront now with Welbeck establishing himself this season and Chicharito sure to do better in his third season. I think we should move Rooney back into midfield now. He is getting older and has the experience to play the position. It would allow us to give Macheda more chances and if we sell berbatov we could sign another striker which I think would be easier and cheaper than signing an established or even a young potential playmaker. Sneijder or Modric would be very expensive and someone like Eriksen or Gotze again expensive. Maybe we could sign Llorente? What do you think?
    I've said this A LOT.. Rooney loves going back to midfield and pick the ball up, track back, cross balls into the box, play long balls every now and then, so I honestly prefer having him as an offensive midfielder or as a second striker and have a main striker in the box (like Chicharito, just staying in the box and getting the service he needs rather than picking the ball up himself as well).. The reason I say this is because even when were playing 4-5-1 Rooney is still most often not in the box, he likes moving around and has great energy.. so i wouldn't so much buy a striker.. Just a play maker, a winger/offensive midfielder and a defensive midfielder maybe
    Reply
  • 17 Mar 2012 6:44 PM

    Re: Time to move Rooney backwards.....

    I think that Rooney's current position as second striker is best for him and the team.

    If you watch him when we are defending, he is always dropping into midfield while the other striker is upfront. If works with Rooney since he's a hardworker and he can cover the field quite well.

    The strikers we have now are good, and I dont think we should be in the market for a new one...
    Reply
  • 17 Mar 2012 6:19 PM
    • Not Ranked
    • Joined on 17 May 2011
    • Posts 400

    Re: Time to move Rooney backwards.....

    Michael Ballard.:
    He has been playing in a deeper role pretty much all season. He should be playing up top, he is most effective there.
    I think he's at his best in the role he has now where he's just behind the other striker. It gives him the option to play up front or drop deeper if he need to.
    Reply
  • 17 Mar 2012 5:31 PM

    Re: Time to move Rooney backwards.....

    I agree that Macheda is not likely to make it here. I still think we should move Rooney back to midfield but only if we sign another striker. I just don't think we can find a midfielder better that Rooney would be for reasonable money. I think we could find another striker though...
    Reply
  • 17 Mar 2012 5:30 PM

    Re: Time to move Rooney backwards.....

    Rooney isn't a midfielder..simple as that.
    Reply
  • 17 Mar 2012 5:28 PM

    Re: Time to move Rooney backwards.....

    jojo22:
    We have so many good looking options upfront now with Welbeck establishing himself this season and Chicharito sure to do better in his third season. I think we should move Rooney back into midfield now. He is getting older and has the experience to play the position. It would allow us to give Macheda more chances and if we sell berbatov we could sign another striker which I think would be easier and cheaper than signing an established or even a young potential playmaker. Sneijder or Modric would be very expensive and someone like Eriksen or Gotze again expensive. Maybe we could sign Llorente? What do you think?
    well firstly,macheda will not pull on our shirt again,he simply not good enough for me,as for rooney in midfield,we just cannot allow 20 plus goals to disappear,we still feel the loss of ronnys goals,so to take away our main threat would be madness,we need to consolidate his goals from midfield,ease the pressure on the guy a tad and just let him play where he preferres.
    remembering games daisy chains and laughs got to keep the looneys on the path
    Reply
  • 17 Mar 2012 5:09 PM

    Re: Time to move Rooney backwards.....

    Rooney will never be what Scholes was/is.
    jojo22:
    It would allow us to give Macheda more chances
    Honestly, I just don't think Macheda is going to make it here. He's been unimpressive in every game he's played (Villa '09, aside).
    20
    Reply
Page 1 of 2 (19 items) 1 2 Next >