Sorry mate you are just being idiotic.

Go back to Fifa/Pes/Fm as it seems you have lost sense of reality. The clubs scouts are qualified and well if you think you could do a better job, take the training and try get a job as one.

I wouldn't go for Tiote or Hazard. Hazard is a winger, and we already have Young, Nani, and Valencia. Our youth academy also seems to have some very decent wingers, and at Hull we have Brady, so no more wingers. As for Tiote, we need a player who is of higher quality. Although Tiote has been brilliant for Newcastle, I don't see him doing much for us. We need someone like Martinez, Strootman, or Eriksen. Eriksen will too expensive, so I'm hoping we sign Strootman and Martinez. Unless, of course, Sir Alex decides it's time to give Pogba a chance and we start with Pogba and Cleverley. I fear Cleverley is injury prone, although I hope it isn't true.

I wouldn't criticize the United scouts. After all, they found Hernandez when no one else did before the World Cup. We snapped him up for what, £7 million? Now, he's easily worth at least 4 times that amount. Also, the scouts spotted Chris Smalling, who wasn't really a hot commodity until we signed him and he had a great season with us. We can also look at Fabio and Rafael, who were signed recently and have been very good for us.

i see where you are comig from with this alot of very good players have left clubs in the past 3 years for fairly cheap and it seems to pass us by...yeah we picked up hernandez for cheap and young didnt cost the world also phil jones de gea was expensive for a young keeper but i think he will prove his worth over the next few years. cabaye, tiote, ben arfa all good buys by newcastle. i think also fergies refusal to pay more than 25m for players isnt great if we are going to keep up with barca and real then we need a couple of players that will cost us around 50m......i think tiote and hazard would be good additions to our midfield and they together would be about 40m

ephysuol:

SOME TIME I WONDER WHAT UNITED SCOUT ARE SCOUTING

Actually unless United tells us, none of us really knows for certain who the scouts have and have not looked at. Even when we hear of scouts being at certain games, we are only guessing which players they are watching.

the reality of football is that there were always be good players we could have signed who play for other clubs, no matter how much we do or do not scout, we simply are not going to sign them all. Other clubs always have and always will have good players on their team.

ephysuol:

SOME TIME I WONDER WHAT UNITED SCOUT ARE SCOUTING. this are the kind of players we should be going for. since we are looking for the best young talents that will serve us for at least 6-7years and also knowing that we dont have the financial power to compete with the likes of chelsea, city,psg and real. these players will suite us. Giovinco with good unimaginable skills and electrifying paste. at round 10-13million euros, good value for money. Luuk de Jong at 21 he has break into the dutch team, with good goal scoring ratio, he would be a good replacement for barbatov. worth 15million euros barca are now interested in giovinco, whom i believe will be an instant heat in any big club with good players around him, when ever i watch him play for parma i see a great talent. take a close look at luuk de young, watch him play, he style of play is amazing just fernando lorrente in bilboa, i hope we sign any of the 2 player a replacement for barba. some times i wonder what our scout are scouting, they know pretty well that this club is indebted, and they cant look around to identify good quality players who are best suited to our style of play and financial status. when ac milan were begging for offers for huntlear, our scout are asleep, when madrid were calling for sjnaider, they were snoring, when masselli were asking for bids for frank reberi, they were busy dreaming, just this past season, vistle made it clear to anderlet that he wants to leave in the summer, with one year left in his contract, they were looking for 5mllion offer, but finally benfica snap him up, what about the young dutch striker that palyed in the dutch league last season kwanski, now making heat in the portugese league. if we had learn to take advantage of such dealing, we would have had a great squard that can with stand the test of time, had we bought this players when the oppotunity came calling, all of them in total would have cost up 70 million. sjniader left madrid for 15million euros. huntlaer left ac milan for 10million euros. frank reberi left marselli for 8million euros. vistle left anderlet for 5million euros. after their move, united will come calling with bid worth tripple of what his current club spent on the player. is time to wake and take advantage of other clubs in getting good quality players for cheap. i dont believe that players who cost much are always better players than other, players like hulk and co, i cant pay 20million for such player.

Having people like u who call themselves a utd fan is the only thing I hate about supporting this great club! Now do one!

Sorry mate but I don't really understand wtf you're getting at. Giovinco is average at best and is not good enough for us whatsoever. Same case with de jong, and even if we sold berba he wouldn't need to be replaced imho. Llorente is good but we have 3 strikers better than him and he'd cost a fortune. Demba Ba is similar to llorente in the fact they're both target men, and Ba is considerably cheaper, proven in the epl, and is still not needed! Huntelaar is having an immense season but is not needed and not worth getting considering he turns 29 this year. Inter only tend to play well if sneijder's playing well, and their league position of 7th says it all. One of SAFs best decisions not to get him. RIbery not reberi is nearly 29 too, and overrated imo. I dk who vistle is. My assumption is axel witsel, who left standard liege rather than anderlecht, and not for 50 mil euros either. Hulk is also hideously overrated. This I'm afraid may well be the worst post I've ever read in all honesty.

ephysuol:

SOME TIME I WONDER WHAT UNITED SCOUT ARE SCOUTING. this are the kind of players we should be going for. since we are looking for the best young talents that will serve us for at least 6-7years and also knowing that we dont have the financial power to compete with the likes of chelsea, city,psg and real. these players will suite us. Giovinco with good unimaginable skills and electrifying paste. at round 10-13million euros, good value for money. Luuk de Jong at 21 he has break into the dutch team, with good goal scoring ratio, he would be a good replacement for barbatov. worth 15million euros barca are now interested in giovinco, whom i believe will be an instant heat in any big club with good players around him, when ever i watch him play for parma i see a great talent. take a close look at luuk de young, watch him play, he style of play is amazing just fernando lorrente in bilboa, i hope we sign any of the 2 player a replacement for barba. some times i wonder what our scout are scouting, they know pretty well that this club is indebted, and they cant look around to identify good quality players who are best suited to our style of play and financial status. when ac milan were begging for offers for huntlear, our scout are asleep, when madrid were calling for sjnaider, they were snoring, when masselli were asking for bids for frank reberi, they were busy dreaming, just this past season, vistle made it clear to anderlet that he wants to leave in the summer, with one year left in his contract, they were looking for 5mllion offer, but finally benfica snap him up, what about the young dutch striker that palyed in the dutch league last season kwanski, now making heat in the portugese league. if we had learn to take advantage of such dealing, we would have had a great squard that can with stand the test of time, had we bought this players when the oppotunity came calling, all of them in total would have cost up 70 million. sjniader left madrid for 15million euros. huntlaer left ac milan for 10million euros. frank reberi left marselli for 8million euros. vistle left anderlet for 50million euros. after their move, united will come calling with bid worth tripple of what his current club spent on the player. is time to wake and take advantage of other clubs in getting good quality players for cheap. i dont believe that players who cost much are always better players than other, players like hulk and co, i cant pay 20million for such player.

Do you honestly think, no offence, someone like you, has more knowledge of the younger cheaper players than possibly the biggest global club? I think not, I am sure all the scouts have tabs on players and quite honestly, if SAF doesn't think they'll fit, who are we to argue, that guy has forgotten more about being a top class manager than we'll ever know.

The fact you have spelt pretty much every player wrong who you mentioned there, shows me the validity of your claims our scouts know nothing. The fact is, people were screaming for Sneijder and still are for some reason, the guy is injury prone and his stats over the last 3 seasons have been shocking, plus, he was demanding that he would have been the highest paid player in the squad, not going to happen, he plays where Rooney plays and refused to sit in a 2 man midfield, glad we didn't get him. This is such a troll post which I wish would never be allowed on these forums, utter nonsense.

SOME TIME I WONDER WHAT UNITED SCOUT ARE SCOUTING. this are the kind of players we should be going for. since we are looking for the best young talents that will serve us for at least 6-7years and also knowing that we dont have the financial power to compete with the likes of chelsea, city,psg and real. these players will suite us. Giovinco with good unimaginable skills and electrifying paste. at round 10-13million euros, good value for money. Luuk de Jong at 21 he has break into the dutch team, with good goal scoring ratio, he would be a good replacement for barbatov. worth 15million euros barca are now interested in giovinco, whom i believe will be an instant heat in any big club with good players around him, when ever i watch him play for parma i see a great talent. take a close look at luuk de young, watch him play, he style of play is amazing just fernando lorrente in bilboa, i hope we sign any of the 2 player a replacement for barba. some times i wonder what our scout are scouting, they know pretty well that this club is indebted, and they cant look around to identify good quality players who are best suited to our style of play and financial status. when ac milan were begging for offers for huntlear, our scout are asleep, when madrid were calling for sjnaider, they were snoring, when masselli were asking for bids for frank reberi, they were busy dreaming, just this past season, vistle made it clear to anderlet that he wants to leave in the summer, with one year left in his contract, they were looking for 5mllion offer, but finally benfica snap him up, what about the young dutch striker that palyed in the dutch league last season kwanski, now making heat in the portugese league. if we had learn to take advantage of such dealing, we would have had a great squard that can with stand the test of time, had we bought this players when the oppotunity came calling, all of them in total would have cost up 70 million. sjniader left madrid for 15million euros. huntlaer left ac milan for 10million euros. frank reberi left marselli for 8million euros. vistle left anderlet for 5million euros. after their move, united will come calling with bid worth tripple of what his current club spent on the player. is time to wake and take advantage of other clubs in getting good quality players for cheap. i dont believe that players who cost much are always better players than other, players like hulk and co, i cant pay 20million for such player.