The views expressed on this noticeboard are expressed by the fans themselves and do not necessarily reflect the views of Manchester United or any of its representatives. The viewing and posting of messages on this noticeboard is subject to the Forum Terms, which can be viewed here.
Faq
Contact Us
Sort Posts:
Previous Next
  • 29 Apr 2012 4:50 PM

    Re: my opinion on in's and outs and the club

    I think some people are being slightly unrealistic with players and prices. Looking at stories over the past few days this is what I think may happen.... INS - Kagawa 12m, Clyne 3m, possibly a striker not sure who, Martinez 30m (I dunno if this is realistic actually but I would LOVE it, if not then another similar midfielder) OUTS - Berba, Owen, Ando, Park, Kuszcack, Macheda, Fabio loan
    Reply
  • 29 Apr 2012 4:38 PM

    Re: my opinion on in's and outs and the club

    You trust ESPN for your football news really. Their main analyst Tommy Smyth has never touched a ball in his life.
    Reply
  • 29 Apr 2012 4:36 PM

    Re: my opinion on in's and outs and the club

    OUT: BERBATOV, PARK, ANDERSON, BEBE, KUSCZAK, OWEN, MACHEDA, POGBA, FERDINAND ONE MORE SEASON: EVRA, SCHOLES, GIGGS, CARRICK, FLETCHER IN: HAZARD, STROOTMAN / MARTINEZ ( Ideally both ), CISSOKHO, LLORENTE VERY INTERESTING ARTICLE .... Hopes it opens the eyes of 'some' fans who are satisfied with current team! http://soccernet.espn.go.com/columns/story/_/id/1055924/ netherton:-manchester-united-young-guns-struggling-to-fire?cc=3888
    Reply
  • 29 Apr 2012 4:12 PM

    Re: my opinion on in's and outs and the club

    Out Bebe,Kuz,Berbatov,Anderson, and fringe players. Which makes a solid 25 million at least. IN Javi Martinez,Eden Hazard/Christian Eriksen
    Reply
  • 29 Apr 2012 12:30 PM

    Re: my opinion on in's and outs and the club

    Funniest post I've tea in a longtime. This is Manchester United mate, not Leeds United! INS: Have to be a CM and CAM/Left Sided Att. IMO this has to be: CM: Martinez, Strootmen, CAM: Hazard, Goetze, If we sign Gaitan I will eat my iPhone! PJ
    Paul_ROX:
    Sell or release: Owen, Berbatov, Kuszczak, de Laet, Bebe Loan out: Fabio, Macheda, Pogba Buy: Marcelo (I heard he gets about 1m per year at Real Madrid), Nicolas Gaitan, Papiss Cisse
    Reply
  • 29 Apr 2012 10:39 AM

    Re: my opinion on in's and outs and the club

    i think, kus, Berba, Pogba, fryers, park, bebe, owen, will all leave(not that i want pogba and fryers to) and i'd like to see anderson shown the door but don't think that wil happen

    dunno about in, Kagawa, Strootman, clyne and fuchs would be nice, but think thats been overly optemistic(espically on the kagawa front, if we could get de marcos i'd be almost as happy)
    You are my Solskjaer my Ole Solskjaer You make me happy when skies are grey
    Oh Alan Shearer was F ing dearer please dont take my Solskjaer away
    Reply
  • 29 Apr 2012 10:24 AM

    Re: my opinion on in's and outs and the club

    stretford77:
    Dazzmondo:
    Anderson - Out (13-16m)
    Just curious but who would pay 16m for him?
    or 14 mil for rio let alone 20?!
    It's so simple to be wise; think of something stupid to say and don't say it
    Reply
  • 28 Apr 2012 8:17 PM

    Re: my opinion on in's and outs and the club

    Out: Berbatov Owen Anderson Kuszczak Park Bebe Macheda (loan) De Laet (loan) W Keane (loan) Fabio (loan) Lingard (loan) Tunnicliffe (loan) In: Hazard, Muniain or Rodriguez Strootman or De Marcos Clyne Baines or Alb***
    Reply
  • 28 Apr 2012 7:57 PM

    Re: my opinion on in's and outs and the club

    Out: Kus, Berba, Bebe, De laet, Park

    In: Strootman/Martinez, Clyne and Hazard/Kagawa

    That seems realistic-ish.

    I will fight until i die
    Reply
  • 28 Apr 2012 7:53 PM

    Re: my opinion on in's and outs and the club

    Loaned - Fabio - To be fair already announced, Amos, King,W.Keane,Tunnicliffe. Released -Kuszczak - Do not know why people saying sell him, he is out of contract. Norwood , James and Pogba. Sold - Berbatov,Macheda,Bebe, Anderson,Park and De Laet Contracts - New 1 deals for Scholes and Owen Signed - Nathan Clyne and Modric Do not foget the return of Vidic and Fletcher - Will feel like 2 new players
    Reply
  • 26 Apr 2012 6:44 PM

    Re: my opinion on in's and outs and the club

    stretford77:
    Dazzmondo:
    stretford77:
    Dazzmondo:
    Anderson - Out (13-16m)
    Just curious but who would pay 16m for him?
    Prob noone but if Alex does sell him I don't think it will be particularily cheep, Anzhi might be an option.
    Cut our losses and move on, you can't always get a profit plus we'll be using the wages more effectively.
    In cases like this a loan with a view to a permanent move might be a good option. If it's a successful loan, then the price is justified or we bring him back, hopefully a better player, or if it fails, then we loose nothing, plus he'll be off the payroll.
    Post whatever rubbish you like and if people disagree then just play the opinion card
    Reply
  • 26 Apr 2012 6:39 PM

    Re: my opinion on in's and outs and the club

    Dazzmondo:
    stretford77:
    Dazzmondo:
    Anderson - Out (13-16m)
    Just curious but who would pay 16m for him?
    Prob noone but if Alex does sell him I don't think it will be particularily cheep, Anzhi might be an option.
    Cut our losses and move on, you can't always get a profit plus we'll be using the wages more effectively.
    Reply
  • 26 Apr 2012 6:32 PM

    Re: my opinion on in's and outs and the club

    stretford77:
    Dazzmondo:
    Anderson - Out (13-16m)
    Just curious but who would pay 16m for him?
    Prob noone but if Alex does sell him I don't think it will be particularily cheep, Anzhi might be an option.
    Reply
  • 26 Apr 2012 6:24 PM

    Re: my opinion on in's and outs and the club

    This is a crucial transfer window coming up for Manchester United, our team is going through a significant period of transition and a number of positions will need to be filled with long term replacements over the next two seasons

    The main priorities for the team should be signing a young talented RB, a Defensive Midfielder and an attacking CM/Playmaker.

    My choices in their respective positions would be, RB- Clyne, DM- Strootman and AM/Playmaker- James Rodriguez/Eden Hazard. I believe this signings would cost us in the region of £40m

    I also expect Kusczak to be sold (£1-2m), Ritchie De Laet (£1-2m), Marnick Vemijl (£1m), Josh King (£1-2m), Michael Owen to be released and Berbatov to be sold for £8-10m. This money would take our net spend to around £30m

    It has already been announced that Fabio will go out on loan (hopefully to someone like Bolton/Swansea, in addition to this i'd to see a number of our other young talents go out on loan. I'd expect to see Paul Pogba (if he signs a new contract), Davide Petrucci, Ben Amos, Michael Keane, Will Keane, Jesse Lingard and possibly Ryan Tunnicliffe go out on loan to a Premiership club like Wigan, Bolton, Everton, Swansea, Norwich or a newly promoted club

    John Cofie, Mats Daehli, Adnan Januzaj, Phil McCullough, Liam Grimshaw, Joe Rothwell, Jack Rudge, Jack Barmby, Gyliano van Velzen and Sam Byrne would all benefit from a move to a Championship/leading League 1 side

    I can see Zeki Fryers, Anders Lindegaard, Park Ji Sung, Ryan Giggs, Will Keane, Anderson and Federico Macheda being used as fringe players and being mostly used for Cup games/games against lesser opposition.

    I personally think these signings are realistic and if they happened our squad would be set up to compete at the very highest level for years to come.

    Reply
  • 26 Apr 2012 6:14 PM

    Re: my opinion on in's and outs and the club

    Dazzmondo:
    Anderson - Out (13-16m)
    Just curious but who would pay 16m for him?
    Reply
Page 1 of 2 (25 items) 1 2 Next >