The views expressed on this noticeboard are expressed by the fans themselves and do not necessarily reflect the views of Manchester United or any of its representatives. The viewing and posting of messages on this noticeboard is subject to the Forum Terms, which can be viewed here.
Faq
Contact Us
Sort Posts:
Previous Next
  • 9 May 2012 12:12 PM

    Re: IF we get kagawa.....do you think this formation will work????????????

    subs: lindegaard, cleverley, valencia, welbeck, hernandez, jones, evra and yes welbeck and valencia would still get lots of game time and I know there great players.
    Reply
  • 9 May 2012 12:06 PM

    Re: IF we get kagawa.....do you think this formation will work????????????

    De Gea, Jones, Ferdinand, Vidic, Evra, Martinez, Schweinsteiger, Nani, Kagawa, Valencia, Rooney
    Reply
  • 9 May 2012 9:55 AM

    Re: IF we get kagawa.....do you think this formation will work????????????

    I think kagawa will be given a free role or as an AM/playmaker but they won't do the same to him like they did to anderson
    Reply
  • 8 May 2012 9:20 AM

    Re: IF we get kagawa.....do you think this formation will work????????????

    90thminute:
    No, this formation is non-existent. If he does come, Kagawa will be a centre-mid, not attacking mid.
    Kagawa is an attacking midfielder and that suits his play better, however, Ƒσя this formation †☺ work we need a better creative centre mid. Cleverly perhaps?
    Reply
  • 8 May 2012 9:10 AM

    Re: IF we get kagawa.....do you think this formation will work????????????

    You have been playing to much football manager,what kind of formation is that,its a sure looser if you ask me,it makes no sence at all :)
    Reply
  • 7 May 2012 8:56 PM

    Re: IF we get kagawa.....do you think this formation will work????????????

    Cr4iger:
    shlongconnery:
    football formations
    This is what I would suggest, this shows the movement of the guys on attack and defence, while we're attacking Martinez move across to anchor the middle, then Cleverley, Welbeck, Rooney, Kagawa and Valencia all a fluid front and then on defence, 4-5-1, I don't think Alba is out the realms of possibility, he's rated around 15 Million if not Alba, I think Baines would be decent, I think we should go all out and make Martinez our main signing, Kagawa around 11 Million, add them all up, Clyne - free, Alba 15 Million, Martinez 30 Million, Kagawa 11 Million, all in all, 56 Million, only 6 million more than we spent last year and look at who we could get with that, don't think there is any need for a new striker and this would give us the speed and attacking threat we need, that is Kagawa's role most of the time but he does normally sit behind the striker as well, I think him and Rooney switching roles would work during the game and this would give them both a massive amount of freedom.

    I like this ^

    There are other options, but this is one of the more realistic line-ups..... Personally I would want us to change formation and so on... But I don't think SAF wants that, so if he sticking with the usual 4-4-2 (well it's really 4-2-3-1, but I don't count it as that...), then this is a good option.

    It wouldn't be very expensive either....

    So if SAF don't change the formation, like I would want, then this is one of the best options.

    If you're looking at this like a 4-2-3-1, Cleverley cannot be a defensive midfielder and can't always go up forward as a result. He can only go forward as a defensive midfielder when the other team sits back and outnumbers the 4 attackers. I don't see Cleverley as this kind of a player. However, if you're making this like a 4-4-1-1, then we will be limited, as Kagawa isn't much of a winger and so will spend much time in the middle. This will leave us choked in the middle and on the right with Valencia being our only wide player.
    Reply
  • 7 May 2012 8:15 PM

    Re: IF we get kagawa.....do you think this formation will work????????????

    shlongconnery:
    football formations
    This is what I would suggest, this shows the movement of the guys on attack and defence, while we're attacking Martinez move across to anchor the middle, then Cleverley, Welbeck, Rooney, Kagawa and Valencia all a fluid front and then on defence, 4-5-1, I don't think Alba is out the realms of possibility, he's rated around 15 Million if not Alba, I think Baines would be decent, I think we should go all out and make Martinez our main signing, Kagawa around 11 Million, add them all up, Clyne - free, Alba 15 Million, Martinez 30 Million, Kagawa 11 Million, all in all, 56 Million, only 6 million more than we spent last year and look at who we could get with that, don't think there is any need for a new striker and this would give us the speed and attacking threat we need, that is Kagawa's role most of the time but he does normally sit behind the striker as well, I think him and Rooney switching roles would work during the game and this would give them both a massive amount of freedom.

    I like this ^

    There are other options, but this is one of the more realistic line-ups..... Personally I would want us to change formation and so on... But I don't think SAF wants that, so if he sticking with the usual 4-4-2 (well it's really 4-2-3-1, but I don't count it as that...), then this is a good option.

    It wouldn't be very expensive either....

    So if SAF don't change the formation, like I would want, then this is one of the best options.

    Reply
  • 7 May 2012 7:55 PM

    Re: IF we get kagawa.....do you think this formation will work????????????

    Kagawa might be a great signing but M"Villa and Hazard would seriously improve our midfield. We also need a RB a LB and a CF Time to dig deep Mr Glazer,
    Reply
  • 7 May 2012 2:19 PM

    Re: IF we get kagawa.....do you think this formation will work????????????

    We need more players in addition to Kagawa imo a world class striker of Gomes/Cavan/ Lourente instead of Welbeck who runs round the pitch but poor goal scorer. A left back of Alaba aptitude in place of Evra and Rio is no longer good use Smalling/Evans. IMO Nani is just like Giggs and Scholes can't defend, loses a lot of balls and doesn't win balls he should be sold to raise fund for new players.
    Reply
  • 7 May 2012 1:22 PM

    Re: IF we get kagawa.....do you think this formation will work????????????

    What about this this formation???kagawa take rooney role, and rooney become our top ST...maybe this season it not work because we dont have anyone that can take rooney role but if we have kagawa it can do it....
    Reply
  • 7 May 2012 12:35 PM

    Re: IF we get kagawa.....do you think this formation will work????????????

    UNITED IS MY HEAVEN:
    As Berbatov's agent said few weeks ago, Sir Alex will now buy players with serious pace to create his last great side before the END. So i could see us looking like this next season:
    Kagawa isn't a DM though he'd hate that.
    Reply
  • 7 May 2012 12:34 PM

    Re: IF we get kagawa.....do you think this formation will work????????????

    munchmore:
    I would rather that we use 4-2-3-1 but use Kagawa, Rooney and Valencia in the 3 man attacking midfield, and then we bought a world class striker to play in front of these three. Such as Cavani, Hulk, Llorente etc. We don't have the cold blooded goal scorer in our team.. Hernandez has the potential but not the skill at the moment to do it at the level you must to be a first choice in our team imo. Welbeck is more suited to play in the 3 man attacking midfield than in the striker position.
    This is exactly what i think
    Reply
  • 7 May 2012 11:31 AM

    Re: IF we get kagawa.....do you think this formation will work????????????

    As Berbatov's agent said few weeks ago, Sir Alex will now buy players with serious pace to create his last great side before the END. So i could see us looking like this next season:
    Reply
  • 7 May 2012 10:46 AM

    Re: IF we get kagawa.....do you think this formation will work????????????

    nemanja fikri:
    90thminute:
    No, this formation is non-existent. If he does come, Kagawa will be a centre-mid, not attacking mid.
    You mean like we change anderson role from AM(at porto) to CM(at man utd)...?????...do you think it will work????
    I don't know if it would work, I haven't seen enough of Kagawa to know if he can play in a midfield two, all I am saying is that the OPs formation doesn't exist.
    Reply
  • 7 May 2012 10:39 AM

    Re: IF we get kagawa.....do you think this formation will work????????????

    football formations
    This is what I would suggest, this shows the movement of the guys on attack and defence, while we're attacking Martinez move across to anchor the middle, then Cleverley, Welbeck, Rooney, Kagawa and Valencia all a fluid front and then on defence, 4-5-1, I don't think Alba is out the realms of possibility, he's rated around 15 Million if not Alba, I think Baines would be decent, I think we should go all out and make Martinez our main signing, Kagawa around 11 Million, add them all up, Clyne - free, Alba 15 Million, Martinez 30 Million, Kagawa 11 Million, all in all, 56 Million, only 6 million more than we spent last year and look at who we could get with that, don't think there is any need for a new striker and this would give us the speed and attacking threat we need, that is Kagawa's role most of the time but he does normally sit behind the striker as well, I think him and Rooney switching roles would work during the game and this would give them both a massive amount of freedom.
    Come Rain or Shine I'm A Red Til I Die
    Reply
Page 1 of 2 (22 items) 1 2 Next >