kerim teoman: United4191: kerim teoman: Call me anything you like. But I am not a hater. I have always been objective about transfers. Dont expect Kagawa to be next Scholes. He can play in similar level as Park, Anderson (when not injured). Telling you again: He is not a kind of player who drives us forward. He can maintain status quo. I am not gonna answer your full of hatred comments. But keep this topic in mind, I will make my first comment 6 months from now. And you all will appreciate my vision...
Instead of just being all pessimistic and trying to act like you know it all why don't you give some reasons as to why you think he will not be able to drive us forward because I for one would love to hear them. Going by your other posts they're bound to be ridiculous reasons but please share them with me.
Good remark. here is my following reasons: 1- he is Japanese. maybe the first japanese in our team. I simply dont think his culture suits to ours. He will be faced with settlement problems. We even saw it with De Gea last year. For Asian I would expect more. AT MOST he can contribute as much as PArk. if you are down with it. then it's fine. 2- When we look at his stats, clearly he is not a monster. For sure he will contribute but i just dont see that quality to be a leading star in our team. 3- Kagawa was our 2nd plan. We headed for Hazard but didn't happen to be true. 4- To be honest we are lacking in Central Midfield position so he should not have been our top priority. Rooney can also play in that position. When u look at the bigger picture we may see Kawaga sitting on the bench most of the time. 5- From my point of view we should sign Top Class Players. Because what this team needs now is players possessed with TOP Quality. Young,Valencia, Nani, Park, Carrick...etc these are all good players but not like world class type. If we are aiming for CL then you know our competitors Real Barca...etc. Then ask this question to yourself: Can Kagawa be considered as star in these teams? or he just sits in the beach and substituated later? I'd rather save 12M and splash to players with the likes of Mesut Ozil, Iniesta....etc
Had a read through your reason's and they are pretty much all ridiculous. You think he will struggle because he is Japanese and his culture is different. Well German culture is very different to Japanese and he settled down fine there. You seem to be almost obsessed with the term "monster which is obviously why you are so in love with Hulk. Your 3rd reason is simply astonishing. You "don't see the quality for him to be a leading star" That alone proves to me you know very little and have seen very little of Kagawa. Hazard may well have been our first choice there is no way of proving that but all i know is Kagawa is no less of a player. As for your "Rooney can play there" reason we will have to wait and see Sir Alex may be planning to Push Rooney further forward. Ozil and Iniesta? Dear God that doesn't even need a reply but all i would say is if Hazard Signed for us you would not be complaining. Ask yourself this, Does Hazard give you another £17m worth of talent?