The Mag1cian:

I really don't want either of them. I'd rather have Tiote, as Kagawa has probably been signed to play where Modric would.

That

www.Rooney:

Modric will be the HM and Scholes long term replacement. I would rather of had M`Vila, but Modric does have EPL experiance, and will do a fantastic job slotting right inro the club. My next target would be Tiote, he is young, talented with great upside, and will be a great DM for the club. Than UTD will have a midfield of Kagawa (ATM), Modric (HM), Tiote (DM)....yeah babay!

Umm...HM&DM are the same thing...or so I've heard

Modric will be the HM and Scholes long term replacement. I would rather of had M`Vila, but Modric does have EPL experiance, and will do a fantastic job slotting right inro the club. My next target would be Tiote, he is young, talented with great upside, and will be a great DM for the club. Than UTD will have a midfield of Kagawa (ATM), Modric (HM), Tiote (DM)....yeah babay!

Yes we need a player that is more defensive i feel having almost signed Kagawa it would be point less to get Modric so Strootman all the way and he is cheaper.

WHONEEDSRON:

Look at Modric's stats. He's overrated.

........ok.........

WHONEEDSRON:

I'd prefer we went after Hamsik

oh god talk about hypocrisy lol

Please stop this strootman nonsense, you people have defiantly not seen him play a match. I myself live in holland and saw strootman play every weak. Although he is a talent but he is nowhere near good enough to join united. Maybe after a few years but n there are better players in the dutch league. The best midfielder last year was Elm, you can watch him with sweden he was by far the best midfielder and much better then strootman. Clasie en maher did also have a better season and if they continue there development then they are much better then strootman.

Please stop this strootman nonsense, you people have definatly not seen him play a match. I myself live in holland and saw strootman play every weak. Although he is a talant but he is nowhere near good enough to join united. Maybe after a few years but n there are better players in the dutch league. The best midfielder last year was Elm, you can watch him with sweden he was by far the best midfielder and much better then strootman. Clasie en maher did also have a better season and if they continue there development then they are much better then strootman.

both would be a dream but i couldnt really decide which 1 out of the 2 both world class players modric has alot of pl experience though so might favour him just a lil bit more

I bet most of you have never seen Strootman play. For me Modric all the way but I also believe that we are in need for a DM. That's why I would suggest M'Vila would be the best buy for us. 21 years old and already a very good young player and would not cost a little fortune like Modric. So I say get M'Vila but it seems that he's Arsenal bound.

Ilkay Gündogan!

Both, Modric should be Scholes replacement and Strootman should be a replacement for both Fletcher and early replacement for Carrick. I see Carrick having 1 more season 2 at best, lets not wait until he's passed it to replace him. Strootman is not the finished article yet so let him come gain some valuable experience under Carrick and playing in the less important premier league games (the ones we expect to win) and come on when the game is won, then replace Carrick when the time is right. But get him now for £14 million and not £30 million in 2 years time.

Both. ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. Despite widespread, popular belief, I may not be the best Manchester United Fanzone contributor in the world.

Strootman....we have a AMC playmaker in Kawaga. Strootman is more powerful, better ballwinner and will score more often. Look like most of the fan want Strootman. He is the man to go Sir Alex. Strootman is a dominate player. Holland would be a better team with Strootman than De Jong. Bad for them, the Hollands coach prefer to use De Jong....now, i think Holland are on the way out of Euro 2012.

nasri didn't make an impact bcoz he was not given enough oppurtunities to prove himself.....but if he comes to united...i think he will become a world class player...amazing dribbler and passing ability....a good playmaker......on the other hand modric will be really expensive....

strootman to add a bit ov bite in midfeild, .another keano. would sort that yaya out over the road. lol