The views expressed on this noticeboard are expressed by the fans themselves and do not necessarily reflect the views of Manchester United or any of its representatives. The viewing and posting of messages on this noticeboard is subject to the Forum Terms, which can be viewed here.
Faq
Contact Us
Sort Posts:
Previous Next
  • 17 Sep 2012 8:00 PM

    Re: FIFA 13 Player Ratings: Man United

    REALISTICALLY: De Gea - 80 Rafael - 78 Evra - 83 Jones - 74 Ferdinand - 84 Evans - 76 Valencia - 85 Anderson - 77 Rooney - 87 Giggs - 80 Smalling - 77 Lindegaard - 76 Hernandez - 82 Vidic - 86 Carrick - 82 Nani - 83 Young - 82 Welbeck - 79 Van Persie - 88 Henriquez - 73 Scholes - 85 Cleverley - 78 Fletcher - 79 Powell - 76 Kagawa - 83 Macheda - 72 Buttner - 75 Bebe - 68 Amos - 67 Johnstone - 68
    Reply
  • 16 Sep 2012 9:55 AM

    Re: FIFA 13 Player Ratings: Man United

    The ratings don't really matter to me cause you can edit them anyway, still they seem harsh from EA on United
    Does anyone ever read these?
    Reply
  • 15 Sep 2012 4:01 PM

    Re: FIFA 13 Player Ratings: Man United

    steveychahar:
    My Predictionfor FIFA 13 - Manchester De Gea - 83 Rafael - 80 Vidic - 89 Ferdinand - 83 Evra - 84 Valencia - 85 Kagawa - 83 Carrick - 80 Scholes - 80 Giggs - 80 Nani - 85 Young - 85 Hernandez - 84 Welbeck - 82 Rooney - 90 Van Persie - 90 Anyone who can rate Evra less than an 84 has no clue on his work rate and consistancy for United, I think he's a remarkable player. Substitutes: Lindergaard - 79 Jones - 80 Smalling - 80 Cleverley - 80 Buttner - 70 Powell - 70 Evans - 79 Players like Jones, Rafael, Smalling, Powell, Welbeck & Hernandez all should have the potential to boost their ratings upon Form on Career mode!
    NO NEED FOR PREDICTIONS real stats are more or less out.
    Ronaldo too far out for him to think about it AAOH ABSOLUTELY SENSATIONAL
    Reply
  • 13 Sep 2012 5:03 PM

    Re: FIFA 13 Player Ratings: Man United

    My Predictionfor FIFA 13 - Manchester De Gea - 83 Rafael - 80 Vidic - 89 Ferdinand - 83 Evra - 84 Valencia - 85 Kagawa - 83 Carrick - 80 Scholes - 80 Giggs - 80 Nani - 85 Young - 85 Hernandez - 84 Welbeck - 82 Rooney - 90 Van Persie - 90 Anyone who can rate Evra less than an 84 has no clue on his work rate and consistancy for United, I think he's a remarkable player. Substitutes: Lindergaard - 79 Jones - 80 Smalling - 80 Cleverley - 80 Buttner - 70 Powell - 70 Evans - 79 Players like Jones, Rafael, Smalling, Powell, Welbeck & Hernandez all should have the potential to boost their ratings upon Form on Career mode!
    Reply
  • 13 Sep 2012 4:23 PM

    Re: FIFA 13 Player Ratings: Man United

    thomas21:
    mb28mbrook:
    Considering Kolo Toure is 82 (on the demo) then all of Utd's squad should be 99
    Evans should be rated higher than this.......
    Savic should be rated higher than Kolo Toure ... and that's saying something
    Been Hacked
    Reply
  • 13 Sep 2012 3:37 PM

    Re: FIFA 13 Player Ratings: Man United

    mb28mbrook:
    Considering Kolo Toure is 82 (on the demo) then all of Utd's squad should be 99
    Evans should be rated higher than this.......
    Reply
  • 13 Sep 2012 3:28 PM

    Re: FIFA 13 Player Ratings: Man United

    Considering Kolo Toure is 82 (on the demo) then all of Utd's squad should be 99
    Been Hacked
    Reply
  • 13 Sep 2012 1:42 PM

    Re: FIFA 13 Player Ratings: Man United

    this is the best rating i'v seein so far. very realistic nd i like the analitic aproach. And my favourite part is evans rating. i personaly would give him 76-77, he posses nothing special to write home about as compared to jones or smalling. i think he's too soft to play for united nd should be sold ASAP!
    Reply
  • 13 Sep 2012 1:26 PM

    Re: FIFA 13 Player Ratings: Man United

    the only thing that pisses me off on your ratings is petrice evra's ratings. you must be mad. some of your reserves are rated 75 nd yu rate evra a meer 78. petrice evra is just as gud nd hard working as valencia if yu ask me. only difference is one is left footed while the other is right footed!
    Reply
  • 12 Sep 2012 3:21 PM

    Re: FIFA 13 Player Ratings: Man United

    d.de gea -:
    volcom:
    THIS VIDEO = UNITED RATINGS http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=81vN8VdOtfU&feature=g-all-lik

    Powell is 65 bebe 63 tunnicliffe vesli 61 and 60 buttners a 70. some harsh ratings ie kagawa and valencia 83 84

    Kagawa-83????????? Valencia, maybe deserves 85. But Veseli is in FIFA 13!!!!! YAAAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! My favourite youth player!
    over petrucci and daehli? strange lol
    Ronaldo too far out for him to think about it AAOH ABSOLUTELY SENSATIONAL
    Reply
  • 11 Sep 2012 8:00 PM

    Re: FIFA 13 Player Ratings: Man United

    volcom:
    THIS VIDEO = UNITED RATINGS http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=81vN8VdOtfU&feature=g-all-lik

    Powell is 65 bebe 63 tunnicliffe vesli 61 and 60 buttners a 70. some harsh ratings ie kagawa and valencia 83 84

    Kagawa-83????????? Valencia, maybe deserves 85. But Veseli is in FIFA 13!!!!! YAAAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! My favourite youth player!
    #thankyousiralex
    Reply
  • 11 Sep 2012 5:05 PM

    Re: FIFA 13 Player Ratings: Man United

    Scholes 88 and Young 86
    Reply
  • 11 Sep 2012 2:47 PM

    Re: FIFA 13 Player Ratings: Man United

    THIS VIDEO = UNITED RATINGS http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=81vN8VdOtfU&feature=g-all-lik

    Powell is 65 bebe 63 tunnicliffe vesli 61 and 60 buttners a 70. some harsh ratings ie kagawa and valencia 83 84

    Ronaldo too far out for him to think about it AAOH ABSOLUTELY SENSATIONAL
    Reply
  • 10 Sep 2012 8:35 PM

    Re: FIFA 13 Player Ratings: Man United

    De Gea 80 (86) Lindegaard 79 (83) Jones 80 (86) Rafael 79 (84) Ferdinand 82 (82) Vidic 88 (88) Evra 81 (81) B├╝ttner 75 (79) Carrick 81 (81) Scholes 83 (83) Giggs 80 (80) Anderson 80 (85) Cleverley 82 (86) Fletcher 78 (80) Kagawa 84 (87) Powell 70 (84) Nani 84 (86) Young 84 (88) Valencia 85 (87) Rooney 88 (90) Van Persie 89 (91) Welbeck 80 (85) Henriquez 71 (78) Trying to be realistic but some people may think I'm underrating MU. But then again as someone else here stated, FIFA usually seriously underrate Man Utd compared to Chelsea, Bayern, City etc.
    Reply
  • 3 Sep 2012 4:25 PM

    Re: FIFA 13 Player Ratings: Man United

    These are probably the closest to realistic ratings taht i could come up with, what do you guys think? GK: Da Gea - 82 (had great season despite a few errors here and there but had best goal saving record in EPL last year, shows great promise for the future) Lindergaard - 78 (he's a great keeper, good to have around as a sub but doesn't show much potential for world class in my eyes) CB: Vidic - 88 (due to injury dropped a bit but i don't think it will effect him that much, one of the best in the world) Ferdinand - 84 (age is finally getting to him, he's still a great player but not the world class star he once was) Smalling - 80 (great player when he plays, shows good promise for the future) Jones - 79 (needs time to develop into a star player but shows great promise) Evans - 78 (good season for him last year but nothing special) LB/RB: Evra - 82 (he's slowly slipping, buttner could takes hes place as 1st team left back depending on hes performances this season) Rafael - 78 (he keeps getting better and better) Buttner - 77 (shows allot of promise, great buy and amazing talent) MF: Kagawa - 87 (bundesliga's player of the year, extremely under-rated in football though he's one of the best players in the game) Scholes - 84 (very composed and solid passer and very good on the ball, great player) Carrick - 81 (low potential player imo, he's at he's limit but still decent player) Cleverly - 80 (england's best player in euros, great potential Anderson - 79 (good player, injuries keep stoping he's development, great potential player though) Fletcher - 79 (not looking good for him, been out for a long time) Powell - 74 (we shall see what the future holds for him) LM/RM: Valencia - 86 (very hart to stop down the right wing, one of best in he's position in the world) Nani - 85 (great potential, can become amazing but is just sometimes inconsistent) Young - 83 (good player, could potentially get better and better) Giggs - 81 (he's still got it, one of the best players ever but he's time is obviously coming to an end soon) ST: Van Persie - 89 (best player in EPL last season, one of best strikers there is in football) Rooney - 88 (united's top scorer last season but 'honestly' overrated in FIFA) Hernandez - 84 (very good at getting into dangerous areas and extremely fast for a pouching striker, needs more play time, great potential in him) Welbeck - 81 (getting better, could become great but there is allot of competition for he's position) Macheda - 74 (still to reach hes potential, has not shown enough yet) Henriquez 72 (shows promise but we have to wait and see how he is in 2/3 years) Bebe - 71 (not so impressive)
    Reply
Page 1 of 2 (23 items) 1 2 Next >