Paula Simpson:

i dont rate carrick much anyway so i think try hargreaves and anderson see how it goes doesnt work giggs in the centre nani on the left

I rate Carrick higher than Hargreavs,Fletcher,Anderson and I rate everyone higher than O'shea.

And Giggs is not so bad in the centre as in the wings.

i think i heard that giggs was going to take a more permanant role in midfield as he is ageing slightley and has not got the speed to run down the left anymore he curtainly has the experience to play any where in the front part of the team, but as for a permanant player with great consistancey we really do need to think about a new sign in janaury before the final stages of the champion league resumes

MANCHESTER UNITED ARE NOT IN CRISIS EVERY TEAM GOES THROUGH TRICKY TIMES !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

now that our first choice central mildfielders,scholes and carrick are out for sometime what do u guys think that central midfield should look like.i think giggs played well against aalborg and showed ha can really marshal the midfield.i dont know though if he can manage when we are under pressure.oshea didnt please me so much.playing as a holding midfielder,he was being out run and is not so solid.he doesnt tackle as much as u'd hope.he's kind of soft.i'd go with giggs and hargreaves if he's fit to play.if not possebon and gibson can be given a chance.what do u think would be the right combination at the centre?