welbeck, reasons? better at dribiling, better shot and finisher, quicker, better in the air..machedas good aswell but i feel welbeck brings alot more to the team and is more complete...i prefer welbeck to play on the wing, rips defenders to apart when he plays there.

They are both talented players but in the limited occassions we saw of them last season I think Kiko is more matured and ready for the EPL than Welbeck. Kiko challenges for the ball and is strong in the hussle and challenges whereas Welbeck is lanky and loose on the ball. They are both still young (Welbeck being younger still) and can improve out of sight within a short space of time, given the chances. That is why I think we do not need another striker signing now we have Rooney, Berbatov and Owen as our front strikers ..... unless of course a truly outstanding striker happens to be available.

They're both going to be great players in their own right. As i've said on these Message Boards before, i believe Welbeck will have more penetration to his play than Macheda as he has superb dribbling abillity and has the ability to do the unexpected. Macheda however is a poacher just an out and out goalscorer however, having watched him a llot in the reserves and academy he can also hit them from outside the box. For next season though, i want to see Welbeck be around the first team and makes atleast 20-25 appearances and Macheda be loaned out as Macheda's not quite ready yet, where i believe Welbeck is, he showed it in his game against Tottenham and Everton, he completely ripped them apart.

definitly Welbeck hes a great little player and i cant wait to see him play some more now the tevez,/ronaldo are gone

I will pick Campbell or Macheda now.

 well its pretty much straight forward... who will you pick ?

i think welbeck is better but i like mecheda more..