The views expressed on this noticeboard are expressed by the fans themselves and do not necessarily reflect the views of Manchester United or any of its representatives. The viewing and posting of messages on this noticeboard is subject to the Forum Terms, which can be viewed here.
Faq
Contact Us
Sort Posts:
Previous Next
  • 19 Sep 2009 11:40 PM

    Re: Man Utd vs Man City line up

    JohnTS.zm:

     My winning line up is as follows:

    Formation  4-4-2

    Goal:  Ben

    Defence:    Rio(John Evans), Vidic, Evra, Oshea

    Midfield:  Fletcher, Anderson, Nani,  Valencia(Park)

    Strikers:  Rooney, Barbatov

    Subs:   Giggs, Carrick, Rafael, Owen,  Kuzhak, Tosic

    Vedict:  Man Utd 4 - Man City 1

    Who is Barbatov???? And Kuzhak? lol

    Foster
    Wes,Rio/Evans, Vida, Evra
    Valencia, Fletch, Ando, Nani
    Roo, Berbatov.

    United to win 3-1

    Reply
  • 19 Sep 2009 11:08 PM

    Re: Man Utd vs Man City line up

     Foster

    Brown   Ferdinand (Evans)   Vidic   Evra

    Valencia   Fletcher   Anderson   Park

    Rooney   Berbatov

     Man Utd - Man Shitty: 2-1

    Patrice Evra running up and down the wing!
    Reply
  • 19 Sep 2009 8:11 PM

    Re: Man Utd vs Man City line up

    plus in diamond what do you mean width comes from right back/left back? in diamond there is a right midfielder and a left midfielder. it's is like having a 4-4-2 with a center defense midfielder or an attacking midfielder.

    When it erh comes to football
    I am a God
    Reply
  • 19 Sep 2009 8:08 PM

    Re: Man Utd vs Man City line up

    ownagemt:

    juelz111:

     

    Amada15:

    ownagemt:

    Amada15:

    ok guys this is my formation

     

                                                                                 Ben Foster(GK)

     

     Gary Neville(rb) cpt.                  Rio Ferdinand(cb)                           Nemjan Vidic(cb)              Patrice Evra (lb)

     

                                                                      Darron Fletcher (cdm)

     Luis Nani/Ryan Giggs(rm)                                                                                                    Ryan Giggs/Luis Nani(lm)

                                                                         Anderson(cam)

                                                   Wayne Rooney(st)                                  Dimiter Berbatov (st)

     

    substitute:  Kuszack, Owen, Carrick, Scholes, O'Shea, Park

    reserve: Fabio, Macheada, Welbeck, Evans, Brown, Gibson, me,

     

    Diamonds don't work with wingers.

     Also Scholes is banned.

                                 Kuszczak

                Fabio     Vidic       Evans       Evra

            Fletcher     Carrick        Ando       Giggs

                               Rooney

                                       Berbatov

     

    Subs: Foster, Owen, Brown, O'shea, Park and whoever.

     

     what do you mean diamond do not work well with wingers? Giggs will play a sort of central role while nani will keep rotating from left mid to right mid. and yea i forgot scholes was banned, i'll replace him with Valencia.

    and in your formation Fletcher is not good at all on the wing. How could you  put him in a new position, when he has been doing so good in the central role? and this season Rooney is playing a more striker role than staying behind another striker. Plus why would fabio play in a match like this? SAF will never do that unless it was the last resort or he has matured. He's going to put O' Shea or Neville in that position. Plus Kuzack in goal? where did that come from? pleaase explain. And SAF playing Carrick is a gamble because his form this season has not been that great. Also, Ferdinand might be fit for the derby match, and i am sure SAF will rather put Ferdinand in that position than a fully fit Evans, because ferdinand is a crucial member in our defense line.

     

    lol REALLY guys?? you're arguing about this??

    I'll argue about it'til death.

    Fletcher can play on right midfield, he did against spurs, remember how that game turned out? It's hardly a new position, it may seem that way if you're new to watching United, but Fletch used to play there before.

    Carrick a gamble? Please, there are no risk-free winners you can just put out. Rooney plays best behind the striker, Berba plays best as striker, what's the problem?

     And Fabio could, and should start. Rafael made his debĂșt(I think it was his debut) against Arsenal, why can't his more skillful brother start against City?

    And Rio, I agree if he can play he will play, but if he's injured which it seems like he might be then Evans will obviously start.

    And in diamonds the width comes from the wingbacks, you'd have to switch Nani with Carrick.

    And Kuszczak is our best 'keeper, he's much better than Foster, newbie fans like you just haven't seen him yet. If you look through the forums you'll see quite a few of them with the majority saying Tomasz should have been playing instead of Foster, but now we're winning they like Foster. 

     

    lol, we are playing Manchester City not Tottneham. Plus Tottenham we played a game without wingers. Fletcher did not play on the wing against Tottenham. If you put Fletcher in the wing are you expecting him to dribble pass defender, or do u expect Carrick to do the role of taking the ball from the defense?  Carrick is not in form this season, and he plays a similar role has Fletcher. Fletcher should sustain his position as central midfield in this match, while we either have nani or valencia on the wing. Giggs will play sort of a central, while Anderson will play center attack  midfield. And once again Fabio is young and should not be put in a match like this, which we can not afford to loose. J'oshea or neville are more defense aware than Fabio. Fabio is more attack minded.  Foster have been doing fornominal in goal, while kuszack have not started a single game this season yet. so putting kuszack in for foster is laughable. He is a good goalie, however at least he should have a game up his sleeves, before playing in a tough match like this.  It is like putting Macheada in for Berbatov.

    When it erh comes to football
    I am a God
    Reply
  • 19 Sep 2009 2:40 PM

    Re: Man Utd vs Man City line up

    juelz111:

     

    Amada15:

    ownagemt:

    Amada15:

    ok guys this is my formation

     

                                                                                 Ben Foster(GK)

     

     Gary Neville(rb) cpt.                  Rio Ferdinand(cb)                           Nemjan Vidic(cb)              Patrice Evra (lb)

     

                                                                      Darron Fletcher (cdm)

     Luis Nani/Ryan Giggs(rm)                                                                                                    Ryan Giggs/Luis Nani(lm)

                                                                         Anderson(cam)

                                                   Wayne Rooney(st)                                  Dimiter Berbatov (st)

     

    substitute:  Kuszack, Owen, Carrick, Scholes, O'Shea, Park

    reserve: Fabio, Macheada, Welbeck, Evans, Brown, Gibson, me,

     

    Diamonds don't work with wingers.

     Also Scholes is banned.

                                 Kuszczak

                Fabio     Vidic       Evans       Evra

            Fletcher     Carrick        Ando       Giggs

                               Rooney

                                       Berbatov

     

    Subs: Foster, Owen, Brown, O'shea, Park and whoever.

     

     what do you mean diamond do not work well with wingers? Giggs will play a sort of central role while nani will keep rotating from left mid to right mid. and yea i forgot scholes was banned, i'll replace him with Valencia.

    and in your formation Fletcher is not good at all on the wing. How could you  put him in a new position, when he has been doing so good in the central role? and this season Rooney is playing a more striker role than staying behind another striker. Plus why would fabio play in a match like this? SAF will never do that unless it was the last resort or he has matured. He's going to put O' Shea or Neville in that position. Plus Kuzack in goal? where did that come from? pleaase explain. And SAF playing Carrick is a gamble because his form this season has not been that great. Also, Ferdinand might be fit for the derby match, and i am sure SAF will rather put Ferdinand in that position than a fully fit Evans, because ferdinand is a crucial member in our defense line.

     

    lol REALLY guys?? you're arguing about this??

    I'll argue about it'til death.

    Fletcher can play on right midfield, he did against spurs, remember how that game turned out? It's hardly a new position, it may seem that way if you're new to watching United, but Fletch used to play there before.

    Carrick a gamble? Please, there are no risk-free winners you can just put out. Rooney plays best behind the striker, Berba plays best as striker, what's the problem?

     And Fabio could, and should start. Rafael made his debĂșt(I think it was his debut) against Arsenal, why can't his more skillful brother start against City?

    And Rio, I agree if he can play he will play, but if he's injured which it seems like he might be then Evans will obviously start.

    And in diamonds the width comes from the wingbacks, you'd have to switch Nani with Carrick.

    And Kuszczak is our best 'keeper, he's much better than Foster, newbie fans like you just haven't seen him yet. If you look through the forums you'll see quite a few of them with the majority saying Tomasz should have been playing instead of Foster, but now we're winning they like Foster. 

    Reply
  • 19 Sep 2009 5:02 AM

    Re: Man Utd vs Man City line up

    4-4-2

                       Foster

      O'Shea   Vidic   Ferdinand   Evra

    Valencia Fletcher Carrick  Giggs

                  Rooney  Berbatov

    Subs:Kuzczask, Rafael, Evans, Anderson, Nani, Owen, Gibson

    Home win 2-0

    Reply
  • 18 Sep 2009 8:47 PM

    Re: Man Utd vs Man City line up

                                                                FOSTER

                              O'SHEA               FERDINAND                  VIDIC               EVRA

                    VALENCIA             FLETCHER                ANDERSON           NANI

                                                             GIGGS

                                                                ROONEY

     

    SCORE: 5-0 NO JOKES

    P.S- TEVEZ GETS HIS NOSE BREAKEN BY VIVA VIDA.


    Reply
  • 18 Sep 2009 5:57 PM

    Re: Man Utd vs Man City line up

                                                    BEN FOSTER

    GARY NEVILLE  NEMANJA VIDIC  RIO FERDINAND/JONNY EVANS  PATRICE EVRA

         LUIS ANTONIO VALENCIA  DARREN FLETCHER  ANDERSON  LUIS NANI

                                    DIMITAR BERBATOV  WAYNE ROONEY

    KUZCZACK

    FABIO

    O'SHEA

    GIGGS

    PARK

    OWEN

    MACHEDA

    Reply
  • 18 Sep 2009 5:12 PM

    Re: Man Utd vs Man City line up

     

    Amada15:

    ownagemt:

    Amada15:

    ok guys this is my formation

     

                                                                                 Ben Foster(GK)

     

     Gary Neville(rb) cpt.                  Rio Ferdinand(cb)                           Nemjan Vidic(cb)              Patrice Evra (lb)

     

                                                                      Darron Fletcher (cdm)

     Luis Nani/Ryan Giggs(rm)                                                                                                    Ryan Giggs/Luis Nani(lm)

                                                                         Anderson(cam)

                                                   Wayne Rooney(st)                                  Dimiter Berbatov (st)

     

    substitute:  Kuszack, Owen, Carrick, Scholes, O'Shea, Park

    reserve: Fabio, Macheada, Welbeck, Evans, Brown, Gibson, me,

     

    Diamonds don't work with wingers.

     Also Scholes is banned.

                                 Kuszczak

                Fabio     Vidic       Evans       Evra

            Fletcher     Carrick        Ando       Giggs

                               Rooney

                                       Berbatov

     

    Subs: Foster, Owen, Brown, O'shea, Park and whoever.

     

     what do you mean diamond do not work well with wingers? Giggs will play a sort of central role while nani will keep rotating from left mid to right mid. and yea i forgot scholes was banned, i'll replace him with Valencia.

    and in your formation Fletcher is not good at all on the wing. How could you  put him in a new position, when he has been doing so good in the central role? and this season Rooney is playing a more striker role than staying behind another striker. Plus why would fabio play in a match like this? SAF will never do that unless it was the last resort or he has matured. He's going to put O' Shea or Neville in that position. Plus Kuzack in goal? where did that come from? pleaase explain. And SAF playing Carrick is a gamble because his form this season has not been that great. Also, Ferdinand might be fit for the derby match, and i am sure SAF will rather put Ferdinand in that position than a fully fit Evans, because ferdinand is a crucial member in our defense line.

     

    lol REALLY guys?? you're arguing about this??

    Reply
  • 18 Sep 2009 5:05 PM

    Re: Man Utd vs Man City line up

    Foster

    Brown if fit ( oshea)                  Rio if fit (evans)             Vidic                Evra

     

               Valencia                                   Fletcher                              Anderson                  

     

                                                             Berbatov

                                        Rooney                              owen

    Reply
  • 18 Sep 2009 12:44 AM

    Re: Man Utd vs Man City line up

    ownagemt:

    Amada15:

    ok guys this is my formation

     

                                                                                 Ben Foster(GK)

     

     Gary Neville(rb) cpt.                  Rio Ferdinand(cb)                           Nemjan Vidic(cb)              Patrice Evra (lb)

     

                                                                      Darron Fletcher (cdm)

     Luis Nani/Ryan Giggs(rm)                                                                                                    Ryan Giggs/Luis Nani(lm)

                                                                         Anderson(cam)

                                                   Wayne Rooney(st)                                  Dimiter Berbatov (st)

     

    substitute:  Kuszack, Owen, Carrick, Scholes, O'Shea, Park

    reserve: Fabio, Macheada, Welbeck, Evans, Brown, Gibson, me,

     

    Diamonds don't work with wingers.

     Also Scholes is banned.

                                 Kuszczak

                Fabio     Vidic       Evans       Evra

            Fletcher     Carrick        Ando       Giggs

                               Rooney

                                       Berbatov

     

    Subs: Foster, Owen, Brown, O'shea, Park and whoever.

     

     what do you mean diamond do not work well with wingers? Giggs will play a sort of central role while nani will keep rotating from left mid to right mid. and yea i forgot scholes was banned, i'll replace him with Valencia.

    and in your formation Fletcher is not good at all on the wing. How could you  put him in a new position, when he has been doing so good in the central role? and this season Rooney is playing a more striker role than staying behind another striker. Plus why would fabio play in a match like this? SAF will never do that unless it was the last resort or he has matured. He's going to put O' Shea or Neville in that position. Plus Kuzack in goal? where did that come from? pleaase explain. And SAF playing Carrick is a gamble because his form this season has not been that great. Also, Ferdinand might be fit for the derby match, and i am sure SAF will rather put Ferdinand in that position than a fully fit Evans, because ferdinand is a crucial member in our defense line.

    When it erh comes to football
    I am a God
    Reply
  • 18 Sep 2009 12:13 AM

    Re: Man Utd vs Man City line up

    Amada15:

    ok guys this is my formation

     

                                                                                 Ben Foster(GK)

     

     Gary Neville(rb) cpt.                  Rio Ferdinand(cb)                           Nemjan Vidic(cb)              Patrice Evra (lb)

     

                                                                      Darron Fletcher (cdm)

     Luis Nani/Ryan Giggs(rm)                                                                                                    Ryan Giggs/Luis Nani(lm)

                                                                         Anderson(cam)

                                                   Wayne Rooney(st)                                  Dimiter Berbatov (st)

     

    substitute:  Kuszack, Owen, Carrick, Scholes, O'Shea, Park

    reserve: Fabio, Macheada, Welbeck, Evans, Brown, Gibson, me,

     

    Diamonds don't work with wingers.

     Also Scholes is banned.

                                 Kuszczak

                Fabio     Vidic       Evans       Evra

            Fletcher     Carrick        Ando       Giggs

                               Rooney

                                       Berbatov

     

    Subs: Foster, Owen, Brown, O'shea, Park and whoever.

     

    Reply
  • 17 Sep 2009 10:49 PM

    Re: Man Utd vs Man City line up

    hmm 4-2-2 i think

                   Foster

    O'shea    Evens (rio if fit) Vidic    Evra

    Valencia   Fletcher    Giggs     Nani

               Rooney       Owen

     

     i dont know citys line up.... i just know that rooney > city.....

    Reply
  • 17 Sep 2009 6:54 PM

    Re: Man Utd vs Man City line up

    My team to play manchester city on sunday

                                       B.Foster

    O'Shea            J.Evans                N.Vidic             P.Evra 

          J.S.Park         M.Carrick        R.Giggs      L.Nani

                            W.Rooney       D.Berbatov

     

               

    Reply
  • 17 Sep 2009 6:47 PM

    Re: Man Utd vs Man City line up

    Ok Guys .. this is my Formation

     

                                                                       FOSTER

                              O'SHEA               FERDINAND                  VIDIC               EVRA

                             VALENCIA          FLETCHER            ANDERSON       GIGGS

                                                      BERBATOV           ROONEY


    We NEED to PLAY with TWO STRIKERS not like Arsenal, Coz MAN UNITED is an ATTACKING TEAM

    We NEED to Show City the DIFFERENCE !!

    GooD LuCk Uniiiiiiiiiited !! <3

    Reply
Page 1 of 2 (21 items) 1 2 Next >