The views expressed on this noticeboard are expressed by the fans themselves and do not necessarily reflect the views of Manchester United or any of its representatives. The viewing and posting of messages on this noticeboard is subject to the Forum Terms, which can be viewed here.
Faq
Contact Us
Sort Posts:
Previous Next
  • 5 Nov 2009 2:54 PM

    Re: Player ratings - CSKA

    Ruud Peru:
    soccer1doc:

    Be honest people ,do you really rate VDs for yesterday game so high? I think he was at fault with 2 goals and would rate him 3-4 max.

    Glad you see things the way they are its amazing how much Van Der Sar gets away with he was at fault yesterday and in my honest opinion against Liverpool too he is beaten so easily at his near post its amazing. If Foster was in goal they would have ripped him apart.

    Agree, VDS is a great keeper, no doubt, but weak performance againts CSKA and almost no one seems to have noticed it, at least I've seen no threads abou it.  We shouldn't be too critical with Foster, he made some mistakes but not to the extend to be ripped apart, I give him some credit for some excellent saves he's made this year.

     

    Reply
  • 5 Nov 2009 1:41 PM

    Re: Player ratings - CSKA

    soccer1doc:

    Be honest people ,do you really rate VDs for yesterday game so high? I think he was at fault with 2 goals and would rate him 3-4 max.

    Glad you see things the way they are its amazing how much Van Der Sar gets away with he was at fault yesterday and in my honest opinion against Liverpool too he is beaten so easily at his near post its amazing. If Foster was in goal they would have ripped him apart.

    Reply
  • 5 Nov 2009 12:36 AM

    Re: Player ratings - CSKA

    Be honest people ,do you really rate VDs for yesterday game so high? I think he was at fault with 2 goals and would rate him 3-4 max.

    Reply
  • 4 Nov 2009 8:25 AM

    Re: Player ratings - CSKA

    8- machada,valencia,evra

    7-fletcher,owen,rooney

    6-neville, brown, johnny,nani, obertan

    5-scholes.VDS,fabio

    MOM -  igor akinfeev

     

    Reply
  • 4 Nov 2009 7:49 AM

    Re: Player ratings - CSKA

    Van der Sar - 6

    Neville - 7+
    Brown  - 5
    Evans - 6
    Fabio -  4

    Valencia - 6
    Scholes - 6
    Fletcher - 7
    Nani - 4 (although 8 for about 15 mins at the start)
     
    Owen - 8
    Macheda - 7

    Obertan - 7
    Evra - 7
    Rooney - 7

    Referee - 6 and -6 for the Fletcher incident
     
    Afkinev - 10
     
    Reply
  • 3 Nov 2009 11:32 PM

    Re: Player ratings - CSKA

    These would be my ratings:

    Van der Sar - 6-


    Neville - 7
    Brown  - 6
    Evans - 6
    Fabio -  5


    Valencia - 6-
    Scholes - 6
    Fletcher - 6
    Nani - 5,5


    Owen - 7
    Macheda - 6,5


    Obertan -7,5
    Evra - 7
    Rooney - 6


    Referee - 0+

    Reply
  • 3 Nov 2009 10:51 PM

    Player ratings - CSKA

    Van der Sar - 6

    Neville - 7+
    Brown  - 6
    Evans - 6
    Fabio -  6

    Valencia - 6
    Scholes - 6
    Fletcher - 6
    Nani - 6

    Owen - 6
    Macheda - 7

    Obertan - 7
    Evra - 7
    Rooney - 6

    Referee - 0
    Reply
Page 1 of 1 (7 items)