Its very difficult to criticise any United player after a performance and result like todays. But as OP has already said ... Carrick is like marmite, he is either over chastised when he plays a bad game and on the same note, hes overally praised when he has a decent game. I think if we sat down together and re-watched the match and solely ...

Well said OP It really makes you wonder how long Fergie thinks he has left To me, it seems hes not building a team for the future and is just getting out what he can with the players he has had for a good while I think the likes of Ferdinand, Vidic, Giggs, Scholes, Fletcher, Carrick, Evra will all roughly finish their United careers ...

Anyone that can possibly defend Fergie after his decisions and United's performance today really need to remove their head from the sand. Im not saying Fergie out or anything ... but this performance is the worst ive seen from United in years .... truly shocking. God knows what Anderson and Cleverley must think when they witness being ...

Time to do away with the Carrick as a first choice player. :)

Anderson instead of Welbeck and i would think thats not far off our best line up.

[quote user="me23"]Carrick has a virus[/quote] Yes ... its called ineffectiveitus .

Agree with OP 100%. Its a shame other posters feel the need to post sarcastic replies, the formation and players he shows are bang on.

[quote user="EffenSeven"]A proper post by a proper supporter. Finding a real supporter on this forum is like finding a needle in a hay stack. I completely agree. We're not going to win every game. Invincible seasons like Arsenals are rare. Spurs got the early goal and made us scramble and they kept that pressure on and grabbed a ...

Its like a nightmare ground hog day, Fergie just keeps on doing it against any half decent side. Kagawa and RVP are utterly wasted with Carrick, Scholes and Giggs playing.

A lot has been said about our performance against Liverpool and the performances of our centre midfield trio that played. Personally ... I would like to see Anderson and Cleverley given a chance because i believe our football is more fluid with these two But i can understand why Fergie has resorted to the safe option of Scholes, Carrick ...